Student Project Allocation
An implementation of Abraham et al's (2007) algorithm for allocation of student projects. See Abraham et al (2007):
This code assigns students to projects according to their SPA-student algorithm, given preferences of students for projects, preferences of lecturers for students, and the offerings of projects by lecturers.
There are three versions of the algorithm, one in javascript, one in R (which uses the javascript implementation, and one older implementation in perl.
Javascript version (js/)
You can try the javascript version right now: https://richarddmorey.github.io/studentProjectAllocation. Full instructions are given; you may not even have to read any further in this document than this.
R version (R/studentAllocation)
As of February 2021, The underlying code to run the R version is now implemented in javascript run using the V8 package.
First, install the devtools package in R. Then use it to install the studentAllocation package from this repository:
devtools::install_github('richarddmorey/studentProjectAllocation',
subdir = "R/studentAllocation")
Using the shiny app
The package includes a shiny app so that you can use the funtions from a graphical user interface. Run it with the shiny_spa_student() function:
studentAllocation::shiny_spa_student()
The interface looks something like this:
Full instructions for using the shiny app are included in the interface.
Read in the input files
Use the functions read_lecturer_file, read_project_file, and read_student_file to read in the respective data files. See fileFormatDetails.txt for more information. For instance, you can read in the example data files that come with the package:
stud_list <- studentAllocation::read_student_file(
system.file("examples/original/students.txt", package = "studentAllocation")
)
lect_list <- studentAllocation::read_lecturer_file(
system.file("examples/original/lecturers.txt", package = "studentAllocation")
)
proj_list <- studentAllocation::read_project_file(
system.file("examples/original/projects.txt", package = "studentAllocation")
)
This will yield three list objects containing the information in the files. If you have your own data files, you can read them in any way you like as long as they're in the same basic format as the lists produced by the read_*_file functions:
| Object | Length | Each element name is | Element contents |
|---|---|---|---|
| Student preference list | Num. of students | A student ID | Char. vector of student project preferences (project IDs) |
| Lecturer preference list | Num. of lecturers | A lecturer ID | Two elements: cap (integer, lecturer cap); students (char. vector, lecturer preferences for students (student IDs) |
| Project descriptions | Num. of projects | A project ID | Two elements: cap (integer, project cap); lecturer (char. vector of length 1, lecturer ID that offers this project) |
Right now, some consistency checking is done when loading files, but none by the algorithm itself, so ensure that your input is clean if you're creating your own input lists (e.g., no duplicate preferences, all IDs accounted for in the respective list files, etc).
Running the algorithm
Use the spa_student function with the list objects just created to run the algorithm:
out = studentAllocation::spa_student( stud_list, lect_list, proj_list )
The result is an list containing all the output. Note that the format of the output has changed since February 2021.
Output
For now, this is just quick and dirty; in the future the output will be easier to work with. You can access the output via the following objects contained in the returned environment:
| Object | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
allocation |
data.frame | Which projects are assigned to each student |
log |
data.frame | The log of events |
unallocated |
char. vector | Which students are unallocated at the end |
unallocated_after_SPA |
char. vector | Which students were unallocated before random distribution |
iterations |
integer | How many spa-student iterations were needed |
Cleaner output
The functions studentAllocation::neat_project_output(), studentAllocation::neat_student_output(), and studentAllocation::neat_lecturer_output() will provide you with neater information when passed the output object. For instance:
Until neater output is available, you can produce nicer output yourself. For instance, you might want to create a tibble containing the student assignments and their ranking of that assignment. You can do it like this:
student_assignments = studentAllocation::neat_student_output(out, stud_list)
The output in student_assignments will look something like this:
student_assignments
## A tibble: 100 x 7
## Groups: student [100]
# student project pCap lecturer lCap assigned student_ranking
# <chr> <chr> <int> <chr> <int> <lgl> <int>
# 1 s1 p1 5 l1 5 TRUE 1
# 2 s6 p1 5 l1 5 TRUE 1
# 3 s10 p1 5 l1 5 TRUE 1
# 4 s27 p1 5 l1 5 TRUE 1
# 5 s74 p1 5 l1 5 TRUE 1
# 6 s17 p2 5 l2 5 TRUE 1
# 7 s54 p2 5 l2 5 TRUE 1
# 8 s56 p2 5 l2 5 TRUE 1
# 9 s58 p2 5 l2 5 TRUE 1
#10 s78 p2 5 l2 5 TRUE 1
## ... with 90 more rows
We can also check the distribution of rankings to see how good the allocation was:
library(dplyr)
student_assignments %>%
group_by( student_ranking ) %>%
summarise(frequency = n() ) %>%
mutate( percentage = 100 * frequency / sum(frequency) )
# # A tibble: 6 x 3
# student_ranking frequency percentage
# <int> <int> <dbl>
# 1 1 78 78
# 2 2 6 6
# 3 3 5 5
# 4 4 1 1
# 5 5 2 2
# 6 NA 8 8
The allocation was very good, with almost 80% of students getting their first choice. Only 8% were given random projects.
Options
You can set various options using the studentAllocation::pkg_options function, including:
| Option | Type | Default | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
randomize |
logical | FALSE |
Randomize the student order at the start? |
iteration_limit |
integer | Inf |
Limit on the number of iterations for the algorithm (Inf for no limit) |
time_limit |
numeric | 60 |
Limit (in seconds) on the time the algorithm runs |
distribute_unallocated |
logical | TRUE |
Randomly distribute the unallocated students after the algorithm runs? |
neat_delim |
character | ; |
Character used to paste together multiple elements in a field in neat output |
log_level |
integer (0-4) | 1 |
detail in logs (0-4). 0 turns off; 4 is maximum detail |
Perl version (perl/)
The main code is in the bin directory. Input files containing details of the student preferences (students.txt), lecturer preferences (lecturers.txt), and projects offered by lecturers (projects.txt) are placed in the input directory. Example input files are offered.
Utility functions for the algorithm reside in lib/studentAllocation.pm.
You may need to install some extra CPAN modules to make the script work, including List::MoreUtils and Tie::IxHash. For an example showing how to install perl modules, see this wiki entry.
To run the code once the input files are in place, run
perl allocate.pl
from the bin directory.
Output files giving the allocations by student (studentsAssignments.txt), by lecturer (lecturerAssignments.txt), and by project (projectAssignments.txt) are generated in the output directory. Examples are given in the output directory.
Students that cannot be allocated by the algorithm will be listed on the first line of the studentAssignments.txt file. Undercapacity projects and lecturers will be given on the first line of their respective files. In cases where students cannot be allocated, turning on random assignment ($distributeUnassigned = 1) in the script will assign the remaining students to undercapacity projects.