GEOKEYFEM_HM

The numerical simulation code of Qi ZHANG. This work was supported by the RGC Postdoctoral Fellowship Scheme (RGC Ref. No. PDFS2223-5S04) and the Start-up Fund for RAPs under the Strategic Hiring Scheme (Grant No. P0043879).

ALERT! ALERT! ALERT! Please DON'T used the M-C UMAT code for 3D, it will NEVER WORK! There are still many bugs! If you have to try 3D, modify the D-P UMAT code!

Buckley–Leverett Displacement

Irregular updates

A benchmark example that concerns the bearing capacity of foundation soil was added on 02/08/2023 (mm/dd/yyyy). The NS-FEM result could match perfectly with the Prandtl solution. The surface of discontinuity was also qualitatively correct. Change the UMAT file (to D-P) in the assemble function.

Another example that tries to reproduce one case from the following paper was added on 06/03/2023 (mm/dd/yyyy). In order to match the reference result, the stabilization (tunning) parameter should be altered (a value of 1 would lead to inconsistent result). However, the effective stress distribution has some spurious oscillations, which is the weakness of SNS-FEM compared to standard FEM. By default, Mohr-Coulomb law is used.

Sloan, S.W. and Abbo, A.J. (1999), Biot consolidation analysis with automatic time stepping and error control Part 2: applications. Int. J. Numer. Anal. Meth. Geomech., 23: 493-529.

! A new "GasHM" folder has been created,
! which describes how to incorporate gas into hydro-mechanical coupling FEM.
+ The folder contains an assembly function, a constitutive model for transversely isotropic geomaterial,
+ one verification example, and one application example.
@@ To run the example, you need to move files to the main directory. @@

Reflection

In a nutshell, trade-off among computational efficiency (Highest: T6 FEM), spurious oscillations (numerical instability: NS-FEM based on T3 linear interpolation), and overly rigid solution (T3 FEM). SNS-FEM is in between.

Functionality

The code simulates a contact problem between a rigid rectangular block with a Mohr-Coulomb soil by using the penalty method (small deformation). The deformation equation is discretized by using the Smoothed Finite Element Method. The direct nodal integration on the smoothing domain is also modified to stabilized conforming nodal integration (SCNI). This is reflected in this file.

Although the current example only considers the deformation field, the code is designed for hydromechanical coupling analysis (poromechanics). Therefore, the pore pressure stabilization technique is included. In addition, for simplicity, the biot coefficient is set to be 1 and Biot modulus is set to be infinite. It should be not too difficult to modify our code for a more general case by using relevant pre-defined matrices such as the Mass matrix "integral(N^T*N)" from this file.

This is the main file. You can run it directly. In the main file, the most time-consuming part is the assembly process, whose function is given in this file. The constitutive file is also called in the assembly process, as shown in the following code block:

[stress_new(:, ino), SDV_new(:, ino), cto] = MohrCoulomb_UMAT(0, Props(ino,:), stress(:, ino), strain_ino_new - strain_ino_old, SDV(:, ino));

This file pre-aseembles a template for the 2 by 2 block stiffness matrix. It makes the actual assemble code more concise. However, it only works for constant biot coefficient/tensor and mobility, i.e., some material properties will not change with (x,y,z).

The assign_tractionBC2 is not used in this contact problem, while it is designed to calculate the equivalent nodal force vector "integral_line(N^T*traction)" in FEM. The user only need to define the traction_f as a function of (x,y,z,time) (P.S. the element-wise multiplication .* should be adopted).

PFEM (Particle-FEM) feature has not been incorporated yet since it will affect the code structure.

The new main file considers a simple 2D Mohr-Coulomb soil consolidation problem. The geometry is the same as the contact problem. The (max) strip load is 0.05 MPa applied in 100 seconds. The top surface is fully drained.

Advice

The code cannot be perfect. It is highly likely that non-convergence will happen if you change some parameters, especially when you want to push the rigid block forward. One scenario that would partially work is WHEN there is no friction, the initial location of the rigid block is {(0.29, 1) m, (0.51, 1) m}, the total displacement (10 time steps) is (0.3, -0.1) m, mesh size is 0.025 m, Mohr-Coulomb model is adopted, and epsp is 1. The PEEQ profile cannot match the standard FEM result.

However, if you consider friction such as making CFRI = 0.5, the original main code will not converge from the first time step. In that case, we have "by accidently" found a new scheme for updating stiffness matrix. This is given in the second main file with name lucky. We CANNOT guarantee that it will work for other examples.

The calculations of the equivalent plastic strain for D-P and M-C models are based on the deviatoric strain: depsp_d.

Output

If you type run main_rigid_contact_prob.m in the MATLAB command window by using default parameters, you will get the following sample output (note the residual norm does not converge to zero, which is still under investigation). Five figures will also be generated:

The undeformed mesh
The deformed mesh
The contour of horizontal and vertical displacements
The contour of (effective) stress field (4 components: xx, yy, zz, xy)
The contour of equivalent deviatoric plastic strain

An overview of the graphical result (NOT reference result!) could be found in the following Tencent document.

LOAD STEP = 1; TIME = 8.64:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 3.0000E+06
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 1.2921E-10; RES = 5.6370E-05
LOAD STEP = 2; TIME = 17.28:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 3.0000E+06
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 2.4044E-10; RES = 1.0359E-04
LOAD STEP = 3; TIME = 25.92:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 3.0000E+06
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 1.7993E-04; RES = 1.4820E-04
LOAD STEP = 4; TIME = 34.56:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 3.0000E+06
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 3.7912E-03; RES = 1.8788E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 1.3685E-04; RES = 1.8766E-04
LOAD STEP = 5; TIME = 43.20:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 3.0000E+06
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 9.3549E-03; RES = 2.2662E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 7.9673E-04; RES = 2.2310E-04
LOAD STEP = 6; TIME = 51.84:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 3.0000E+06
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 2.3144E-02; RES = 2.5181E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 3.9380E-03; RES = 2.4277E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 8.6805E-04; RES = 2.4141E-04
LOAD STEP = 7; TIME = 60.48:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 3.0000E+06
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 4.0250E-02; RES = 2.6959E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 1.0140E-02; RES = 2.5473E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 2.8344E-03; RES = 2.5249E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 7.6317E-04; RES = 2.5204E-04
LOAD STEP = 8; TIME = 69.12:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 3.0000E+06
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 5.6692E-02; RES = 2.7744E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 2.0020E-02; RES = 2.5996E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 7.0351E-03; RES = 2.5681E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 2.4637E-03; RES = 2.5616E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 9.2800E-04; RES = 2.5595E-04
LOAD STEP = 9; TIME = 77.76:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 3.0000E+06
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 1.2716E-01; RES = 2.9601E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 4.6294E-02; RES = 2.6010E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 1.9707E-02; RES = 2.5343E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 7.3479E-03; RES = 2.5172E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 3.2769E-03; RES = 2.5123E-04
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 1.3195E-03; RES = 2.5108E-04
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 6.0660E-04; RES = 2.5103E-04
LOAD STEP = 10; TIME = 86.40:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 3.0000E+06
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 2.0702E-01; RES = 2.8667E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 8.3940E-02; RES = 2.5344E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 3.6587E-02; RES = 2.4616E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 1.5123E-02; RES = 2.4407E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 6.9927E-03; RES = 2.4348E-04
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 3.1249E-03; RES = 2.4328E-04
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 1.5108E-03; RES = 2.4321E-04
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 7.1468E-04; RES = 2.4318E-04

Sample output from MATLAB command window of the Sloan and Abbo (1999) case.

LOAD STEP = 1; TIME = 54912.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.1227E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 8.1434E-16; RES = 2.2457E-18
LOAD STEP = 2; TIME = 109824.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.1535E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 9.9107E-16; RES = 3.2208E-18
LOAD STEP = 3; TIME = 164736.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.1675E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 5.9210E-16; RES = 3.1756E-18
LOAD STEP = 4; TIME = 219648.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.1770E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 1.3337E-15; RES = 4.2471E-18
LOAD STEP = 5; TIME = 274560.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.1843E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 8.5926E-16; RES = 5.5007E-18
LOAD STEP = 6; TIME = 329472.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.1900E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 9.9942E-16; RES = 5.1807E-18
LOAD STEP = 7; TIME = 384384.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.1947E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 6.9998E-16; RES = 6.6937E-18
LOAD STEP = 8; TIME = 439296.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.1987E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 1.1167E-15; RES = 6.2070E-18
LOAD STEP = 9; TIME = 494208.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.2021E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 1.0974E-15; RES = 8.1017E-18
LOAD STEP = 10; TIME = 549120.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.2050E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 1.4282E-15; RES = 1.2130E-17
LOAD STEP = 11; TIME = 604032.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.2075E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 1.6619E-15; RES = 1.1986E-17
LOAD STEP = 12; TIME = 658944.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.2097E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 1.6714E-15; RES = 1.2456E-17
LOAD STEP = 13; TIME = 713856.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.2116E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 1.9280E-15; RES = 1.4375E-17
LOAD STEP = 14; TIME = 768768.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.2134E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 2.3475E-15; RES = 1.3598E-17
LOAD STEP = 15; TIME = 823680.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.2149E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 1.8821E-15; RES = 1.6759E-17
LOAD STEP = 16; TIME = 878592.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.2163E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 5.9282E-02; RES = 1.4077E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 1.7251E-02; RES = 5.6235E-05
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 5.3367E-03; RES = 1.6574E-05
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 1.7135E-03; RES = 5.4498E-06
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 5.5869E-04; RES = 1.7930E-06
LOAD STEP = 17; TIME = 933504.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.2248E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 1.8878E-01; RES = 4.4363E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 8.7506E-02; RES = 2.2014E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 4.0936E-02; RES = 1.1133E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 1.9256E-02; RES = 5.1410E-05
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 9.1063E-03; RES = 2.4224E-05
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 4.3156E-03; RES = 1.1464E-05
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 2.0473E-03; RES = 5.4355E-06
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 9.7172E-04; RES = 2.5791E-06
LOAD STEP = 18; TIME = 988416.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.2678E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 3.0228E-01; RES = 5.6179E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 1.3697E-01; RES = 3.9522E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 6.7840E-02; RES = 1.9324E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 3.4228E-02; RES = 1.0421E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 1.7583E-02; RES = 5.3954E-05
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 9.0712E-03; RES = 2.8239E-05
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 4.6987E-03; RES = 1.4671E-05
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 2.4369E-03; RES = 7.6336E-06
	 NEWTON = 10; ERROR = 1.2651E-03; RES = 3.9665E-06
	 NEWTON = 11; ERROR = 6.5700E-04; RES = 2.0615E-06
LOAD STEP = 19; TIME = 1043328.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.3448E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 3.2826E-01; RES = 6.6891E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 1.5563E-01; RES = 4.1836E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 7.8011E-02; RES = 2.1222E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 4.0110E-02; RES = 1.1683E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 2.1013E-02; RES = 6.2496E-05
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 1.1083E-02; RES = 3.3580E-05
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 5.8728E-03; RES = 1.7932E-05
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 3.1184E-03; RES = 9.5720E-06
	 NEWTON = 10; ERROR = 1.6579E-03; RES = 5.1018E-06
	 NEWTON = 11; ERROR = 8.8195E-04; RES = 2.7183E-06
LOAD STEP = 20; TIME = 1098240.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.4358E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 3.8215E-01; RES = 7.1713E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 1.8337E-01; RES = 5.1262E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 9.9352E-02; RES = 2.6585E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 5.5052E-02; RES = 1.6244E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 3.1300E-02; RES = 9.4258E-05
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 1.7947E-02; RES = 5.5406E-05
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 1.0358E-02; RES = 3.2275E-05
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 5.9966E-03; RES = 1.8824E-05
	 NEWTON = 10; ERROR = 3.5623E-03; RES = 1.0949E-05
	 NEWTON = 11; ERROR = 2.1007E-03; RES = 6.5585E-06
	 NEWTON = 12; ERROR = 1.2466E-03; RES = 3.9087E-06
	 NEWTON = 13; ERROR = 7.4000E-04; RES = 2.3298E-06
LOAD STEP = 21; TIME = 1153152.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.5380E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 4.2060E-01; RES = 7.8419E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 2.0295E-01; RES = 6.1491E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 1.1213E-01; RES = 3.4064E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 6.3708E-02; RES = 2.1083E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 3.7118E-02; RES = 1.2587E-04
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 2.1843E-02; RES = 7.5971E-05
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 1.2948E-02; RES = 4.5563E-05
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 7.7035E-03; RES = 2.7341E-05
	 NEWTON = 10; ERROR = 4.5943E-03; RES = 1.6382E-05
	 NEWTON = 11; ERROR = 2.7437E-03; RES = 9.8132E-06
	 NEWTON = 12; ERROR = 1.6399E-03; RES = 5.8757E-06
	 NEWTON = 13; ERROR = 9.8066E-04; RES = 3.5175E-06
LOAD STEP = 22; TIME = 1208064.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.7307E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 4.3036E-01; RES = 8.5023E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 2.2446E-01; RES = 6.2120E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 1.2549E-01; RES = 3.9631E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 7.3868E-02; RES = 2.5254E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 4.4513E-02; RES = 1.5829E-04
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 2.7164E-02; RES = 9.9154E-05
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 1.6705E-02; RES = 6.1924E-05
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 1.0320E-02; RES = 3.8637E-05
	 NEWTON = 10; ERROR = 6.3937E-03; RES = 2.4083E-05
	 NEWTON = 11; ERROR = 3.9681E-03; RES = 1.5004E-05
	 NEWTON = 12; ERROR = 2.4654E-03; RES = 9.3446E-06
	 NEWTON = 13; ERROR = 1.5328E-03; RES = 5.8184E-06
	 NEWTON = 14; ERROR = 9.5333E-04; RES = 3.6224E-06
LOAD STEP = 23; TIME = 1262976.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 1.9366E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 4.7899E-01; RES = 9.3927E-04
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 2.4280E-01; RES = 7.4683E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 1.3825E-01; RES = 4.5767E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 8.2084E-02; RES = 2.9585E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 4.9993E-02; RES = 1.8755E-04
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 3.0864E-02; RES = 1.1926E-04
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 1.9219E-02; RES = 7.5555E-05
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 1.2437E-02; RES = 4.7717E-05
	 NEWTON = 10; ERROR = 7.8299E-03; RES = 3.0868E-05
	 NEWTON = 11; ERROR = 4.9830E-03; RES = 1.9612E-05
	 NEWTON = 12; ERROR = 3.1685E-03; RES = 1.2551E-05
	 NEWTON = 13; ERROR = 2.0180E-03; RES = 8.0116E-06
	 NEWTON = 14; ERROR = 1.2859E-03; RES = 5.1154E-06
	 NEWTON = 15; ERROR = 8.1972E-04; RES = 3.2648E-06
LOAD STEP = 24; TIME = 1317888.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 2.1283E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 5.2344E-01; RES = 1.0167E-03
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 2.5222E-01; RES = 8.6282E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 1.4478E-01; RES = 5.0159E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 8.6161E-02; RES = 3.2952E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 5.2855E-02; RES = 2.0926E-04
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 3.2865E-02; RES = 1.3424E-04
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 2.0626E-02; RES = 8.5710E-05
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 1.3014E-02; RES = 5.4742E-05
	 NEWTON = 10; ERROR = 8.2402E-03; RES = 3.4923E-05
	 NEWTON = 11; ERROR = 5.2286E-03; RES = 2.2271E-05
	 NEWTON = 12; ERROR = 3.3223E-03; RES = 1.4196E-05
	 NEWTON = 13; ERROR = 2.1128E-03; RES = 9.0471E-06
	 NEWTON = 14; ERROR = 1.3444E-03; RES = 5.7645E-06
	 NEWTON = 15; ERROR = 8.5576E-04; RES = 3.6725E-06
LOAD STEP = 25; TIME = 1372800.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 2.3095E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 5.2305E-01; RES = 1.1920E-03
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 2.5959E-01; RES = 9.2011E-04
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 1.5209E-01; RES = 5.4034E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 9.1945E-02; RES = 3.5685E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 5.7951E-02; RES = 2.3151E-04
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 3.7969E-02; RES = 1.5905E-04
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 2.4400E-02; RES = 1.0301E-04
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 1.6125E-02; RES = 6.9443E-05
	 NEWTON = 10; ERROR = 1.0507E-02; RES = 4.5426E-05
	 NEWTON = 11; ERROR = 6.9587E-03; RES = 3.0377E-05
	 NEWTON = 12; ERROR = 4.5663E-03; RES = 1.9951E-05
	 NEWTON = 13; ERROR = 3.0250E-03; RES = 1.3283E-05
	 NEWTON = 14; ERROR = 1.9921E-03; RES = 8.7458E-06
	 NEWTON = 15; ERROR = 1.3193E-03; RES = 5.8074E-06
	 NEWTON = 16; ERROR = 8.7049E-04; RES = 3.8301E-06
LOAD STEP = 26; TIME = 1427712.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 2.5385E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 5.4827E-01; RES = 1.1745E-03
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 2.7754E-01; RES = 1.0086E-03
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 1.6409E-01; RES = 6.1977E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 1.0309E-01; RES = 4.3100E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 6.6641E-02; RES = 2.9251E-04
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 4.4137E-02; RES = 2.0343E-04
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 2.9435E-02; RES = 1.3970E-04
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 1.9865E-02; RES = 9.6442E-05
	 NEWTON = 10; ERROR = 1.3430E-02; RES = 6.6107E-05
	 NEWTON = 11; ERROR = 9.1332E-03; RES = 4.5428E-05
	 NEWTON = 12; ERROR = 6.2132E-03; RES = 3.1098E-05
	 NEWTON = 13; ERROR = 4.2391E-03; RES = 2.1321E-05
	 NEWTON = 14; ERROR = 2.8920E-03; RES = 1.4587E-05
	 NEWTON = 15; ERROR = 1.9760E-03; RES = 9.9895E-06
	 NEWTON = 16; ERROR = 1.3499E-03; RES = 6.8331E-06
	 NEWTON = 17; ERROR = 9.2291E-04; RES = 4.6767E-06
LOAD STEP = 27; TIME = 1482624.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 2.7922E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 5.9830E-01; RES = 1.2990E-03
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 2.9925E-01; RES = 1.1797E-03
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 1.8145E-01; RES = 7.3203E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 1.1442E-01; RES = 5.2286E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 7.4730E-02; RES = 3.6161E-04
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 4.9929E-02; RES = 2.5330E-04
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 3.3652E-02; RES = 1.7549E-04
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 2.2922E-02; RES = 1.2217E-04
	 NEWTON = 10; ERROR = 1.5662E-02; RES = 8.4577E-05
	 NEWTON = 11; ERROR = 1.0755E-02; RES = 5.8693E-05
	 NEWTON = 12; ERROR = 7.3950E-03; RES = 4.0608E-05
	 NEWTON = 13; ERROR = 5.0972E-03; RES = 2.8133E-05
	 NEWTON = 14; ERROR = 3.5151E-03; RES = 1.9458E-05
	 NEWTON = 15; ERROR = 2.4271E-03; RES = 1.3468E-05
	 NEWTON = 16; ERROR = 1.6761E-03; RES = 9.3140E-06
	 NEWTON = 17; ERROR = 1.1582E-03; RES = 6.4440E-06
	 NEWTON = 18; ERROR = 8.0040E-04; RES = 4.4561E-06
LOAD STEP = 28; TIME = 1537536.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 3.0481E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 5.7907E-01; RES = 1.4483E-03
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 3.0359E-01; RES = 1.2831E-03
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 1.8238E-01; RES = 8.0851E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 1.1821E-01; RES = 5.8300E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 7.8675E-02; RES = 4.0057E-04
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 5.3650E-02; RES = 2.8629E-04
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 3.6605E-02; RES = 2.0082E-04
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 2.5376E-02; RES = 1.4235E-04
	 NEWTON = 10; ERROR = 1.7709E-02; RES = 1.0354E-04
	 NEWTON = 11; ERROR = 1.2417E-02; RES = 7.2494E-05
	 NEWTON = 12; ERROR = 8.7214E-03; RES = 5.1575E-05
	 NEWTON = 13; ERROR = 6.1413E-03; RES = 3.6435E-05
	 NEWTON = 14; ERROR = 4.3276E-03; RES = 2.5800E-05
	 NEWTON = 15; ERROR = 3.0537E-03; RES = 1.8247E-05
	 NEWTON = 16; ERROR = 2.1554E-03; RES = 1.2907E-05
	 NEWTON = 17; ERROR = 1.5224E-03; RES = 9.1284E-06
	 NEWTON = 18; ERROR = 1.0755E-03; RES = 6.4548E-06
	 NEWTON = 19; ERROR = 7.6001E-04; RES = 4.5646E-06
LOAD STEP = 29; TIME = 1592448.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 3.3192E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 5.7145E-01; RES = 1.6173E-03
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 3.1238E-01; RES = 1.4906E-03
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 1.8984E-01; RES = 8.8385E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 1.2478E-01; RES = 6.6756E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 8.2836E-02; RES = 4.5919E-04
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 5.6979E-02; RES = 3.3324E-04
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 3.9101E-02; RES = 2.3405E-04
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 2.7339E-02; RES = 1.6780E-04
	 NEWTON = 10; ERROR = 1.9068E-02; RES = 1.1841E-04
	 NEWTON = 11; ERROR = 1.3432E-02; RES = 8.4479E-05
	 NEWTON = 12; ERROR = 9.4430E-03; RES = 5.9739E-05
	 NEWTON = 13; ERROR = 6.6746E-03; RES = 4.2505E-05
	 NEWTON = 14; ERROR = 4.7111E-03; RES = 3.0088E-05
	 NEWTON = 15; ERROR = 3.3353E-03; RES = 2.1375E-05
	 NEWTON = 16; ERROR = 2.3590E-03; RES = 1.5140E-05
	 NEWTON = 17; ERROR = 1.6714E-03; RES = 1.0746E-05
	 NEWTON = 18; ERROR = 1.1834E-03; RES = 7.6141E-06
	 NEWTON = 19; ERROR = 8.3874E-04; RES = 5.4016E-06
LOAD STEP = 30; TIME = 1647360.00:
	 NEWTON = 1; ERROR = 1.0000E+00; RES = 3.7058E-03
	 NEWTON = 2; ERROR = 6.2906E-01; RES = 1.7245E-03
	 NEWTON = 3; ERROR = 3.2952E-01; RES = 1.7021E-03
	 NEWTON = 4; ERROR = 2.0047E-01; RES = 9.9402E-04
	 NEWTON = 5; ERROR = 1.3036E-01; RES = 7.4563E-04
	 NEWTON = 6; ERROR = 8.8999E-02; RES = 5.1053E-04
	 NEWTON = 7; ERROR = 6.1408E-02; RES = 4.3320E-04
	 NEWTON = 8; ERROR = 4.3126E-02; RES = 2.6721E-04
	 NEWTON = 9; ERROR = 3.1083E-02; RES = 2.2538E-04
	 NEWTON = 10; ERROR = 2.2587E-02; RES = 1.5549E-04
	 NEWTON = 11; ERROR = 1.6223E-02; RES = 1.1925E-04
	 NEWTON = 12; ERROR = 1.1936E-02; RES = 8.5683E-05
	 NEWTON = 13; ERROR = 8.6429E-03; RES = 6.4495E-05
	 NEWTON = 14; ERROR = 6.3722E-03; RES = 4.6843E-05
	 NEWTON = 15; ERROR = 4.6447E-03; RES = 3.5038E-05
	 NEWTON = 16; ERROR = 3.4255E-03; RES = 2.5446E-05
	 NEWTON = 17; ERROR = 2.5060E-03; RES = 1.9028E-05
	 NEWTON = 18; ERROR = 1.8477E-03; RES = 1.3779E-05
	 NEWTON = 19; ERROR = 1.3547E-03; RES = 1.0340E-05
	 NEWTON = 20; ERROR = 9.9847E-04; RES = 7.4423E-06

To do list

Divide the contact surface into many small segments to see the effectiveness.
Consider objective stress rate (by spin tensor w).
Re-meshing strategy for large deformation simulation.

Important computer folders

By default, computer folders are based on the LG laptop.

Key

C:\Users\zq112\Desktop\ (COMSOL notes)
E:\Numerical simulation\COMSOL_NEWsimulations\Zhang2021_CMAT_2nd_example.mph (Published paper that uses COMSOL)
E:\Postdoc_PolyU\Coder_MEX\GEOKEYFEM_HM (Github repo)
C:\Users\zq112\OneDrive\REMOTE_SYNC\F\CSE583_Analytical and Numerical Methods in Geotechnical Engineering (Useful functions such as the anisotropic elasticity or EVP or isotropic function)
Overleaf CSE583 Notes about MCC

On-going paper and revision

C:\Users\CEE\Desktop\kapp\main_test_validate_coal_Aug08.m + main_test_for_COMSOL.m (Remote PolyU computer)
C:\Users\CEE\Desktop\kapp\New_simulations\Gas_transfer_PLA_ksdiff(surf_dif)_perm_bedding_BN=BP_add_newadsorption_PLASTIC.mph (Remote PolyU computer) (Permeability is isotropic, but elastic tensor isn't, theta = pi/6)
√ C:\Users\zq112\OneDrive\期刊论文修改发表2022\JMPS_or_IJNAG\Revision (Compare adsorbed mass functions)
√ C:\GEOKEYFEM_HM\gas_data (ASUS Gaming Laptop)

================

√ C:\Users\zq112\OneDrive\REMOTE_SYNC\E\Postdoc_PolyU\Shale_gas_on_2022_not_published\Verification\New_case_anisotropy_3D.mph (For verification)
√ C:\Users\zq112\OneDrive\REMOTE_SYNC\E\Postdoc_PolyU\Shale_gas_on_2022_not_published\POROELASTIC_CONSTANTS.xlsx
√ C:\Users\zq112\OneDrive\REMOTE_SYNC\E\Postdoc_PolyU\Shale_gas_on_2022_not_published\Revised_results.ai
C:\Users\CEE\Desktop\3D_reservoir_COMSOL (Remote PolyU computer, see Excel subfolder)
C:\Users\CEE\Desktop Verification_3D1_ANISOTROPIC_horizontal_!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!_IMPORTANT.mph on the Desktop folder of the remote PolyU computer

Finite strain solid mechanics

C:\Users\zq112\OneDrive\REMOTE_SYNC\Nonlinear FEA & C. Linder
C:\Users\zq112\OneDrive\REMOTE_SYNC\E\Postdoc_PolyU\NFEA
C:\Users\zq112\OneDrive\REMOTE_SYNC\E\Postdoc_PolyU\NFEA\T3_Solid_To_ZQ

Group

C:\Users\zq112\Desktop\SNS-FEM-MCC-NEW3 (MCC + large deformation remesh)
C:\Users\zq112\OneDrive\REMOTE_SYNC\E\Postdoc_PolyU\Zeyu_WANG\FEMCON_T3T36 (Standard FEM, coded by Ze-Yu WANG)
C:\Users\zq112\OneDrive\REMOTE_SYNC\E\FEM_HM_T6T3 (Standard FEM, coded by Xianhan WU)

Hydrate

C:\Users\zq112\Desktop\1D_hydrate\reproduce_Klar.m
C:\Users\zq112\Desktop\1D_hydrate\plot_compare.m
C:\Users\CEE\Desktop\1D_hydrate\main_solve_thermo_Masuda2_true_sequential.m (Remote PolyU computer)
C:\Users\zq112\OneDrive\REMOTE_SYNC\F\CSE583_Analytical and Numerical Methods in Geotechnical Engineering\DP_drained_or_undrained (optional)\CDtest_Hydrate_Sh.m

qizhang94 / GEOKEYFEM_HM