This project is an example of a .NET implementation of a medical prescription model using the "Domain-Driven Design" (DDD) approach and the "Command and Query Responsibility Segregation" (CQRS) architectural pattern.
Points of interest
The goal of the project is to experiment with some .NET implementations of the core concepts of DDD (entities, value objects, domain events, ...) and CQRS (commands, queries, command and query handlers, ...) on the basis of a concrete model.
Only a light version of CQRS (no data projection, one data store) has been considered.
Model
The model considered reflects the life cycle of a medical prescription and, in particular, of a pharmaceutical prescription. This life cycle can be summarized by the following diagram.
The current model only takes into account the use cases related to the prescriber : the creation and revocation of a prescription.
Command Model
On the write side, a rich domain model has been used to encapsulate the business logic and to control the creation of domain events. This model represents the business model. It incorporates both behavior and data, and is composed of entities and value objects.
The domain modeling has been focused on two important aspects :
- Encapsulation (to ensure that the aggregate is in a consistent state at all times)
- Separation of concerns (also known as persistence ignorance)
Therefore, the domain model has been implemented as an object model without public setters and by hiding some information (like database identifiers for the value objects). Entity inheritance and value object inheritance has been used and some value types like enumerations has been implemented as value objects.
Two options has been considered to map the domain objects to the database tables :
- Mapping the domain model directly to the database by using a flexible and mature ORM like NHibernate 5 (branch nhibernate).
- Mapping the domain model to an intermediate model (state or persistence model) and then mapping the intermediate model to the database by using a less flexible and mature ORM like Entity Framework Core (branch entityframework).
By comparing the purity/complexity ratios of the two options, the first option is preferred to map the domain model to the database. In the branch "NHibernate", some minor changes have been made to the domain model, such as adding protected constructors or private setters.
The interactions between the main components on the write side can be represented as follows :
Query Model
As mentioned above, the command and query data stores are not differentiated but the architecture on the query side is simplified (as shown on the following diagram). The query side is composed of simple Data Transfer Objects mapped to the database by using the Micro ORM Dapper.
Projects
The libraries are distributed by component (bounded context) :
- The "Core" libraries include the core components (Entity, ValueObject, CommandHandler, ...) necessary to implement the DDD approach according to the CQRS architectural pattern.
- The "Common" libraries include common components (EmailAddress, FullName, ...) that can be reused in multiple bounded contexts (shared kernel).
- The "HealthcareDelivery" libraries include components related to the context of healthcare delivery.
The application layer can be tested by using the "DDD.HealthcareDelivery.IntegrationTests" project.
Cross-cutting concerns
The decorator pattern is especially useful in CQRS to handle cross-cutting concerns such as logging or error handling. Command or query handlers (small interfaces) can be easily decorated. You will find some examples of decorators in the "DDD.Core.Polly" and "DDD.Core" projects.
Exception chaining (or exception wrapping) has been used. Each abstraction has its own set of exceptions :
- ISerializer throws a SerializationException
- IObjectMapper or IObjectTranslator throws a MappingException
- IRepository throws a RepositoryException
- IQueryHandler throws a QueryException
- ICommandHandler throws a CommandException
The Domain and Application layers have their own base exception class (respectively DomainException and ApplicationException). These classes defines a property IsTransient indicating whether the exception is transient.