The purpose of this project is to try to understand the type and scale of the moderation of the Hacker News Front Page.
NOTE: I love Hacker News. I try to read it every day. In the case of OnnxStream (here for example), 95% of the comments were helpful and intelligent. I also understand that moderating a site with huge traffic and where users are basically anonymous must be a very difficult task.
Returning to the purpose of this project, from what I have been able to see, the "public" (i.e. observable from the outside) moderation of the Front Page consists of two main tools: modification of the title of a Story (voluntarily or involuntarily influencing its growth in terms of rank) or directly its removal.
Regarding the first type of moderation, an excellent site is already available that tracks changes to Story titles. Here instead I will focus on the second type.
For the reasons explained in the "Why?" section below, I have developed a small application that logs all the Stories that are removed from the Front Page, for personal use. I later discovered that there is no tool/website that provides this type of information and I decided to make it public here. It was a difficult decision but my rationale is: is it better to have more transparency or less transparency?
If you know of a tool/website similar to this, please let me know: I will archive this repo or set it to private.
A possible very positive outcome for this project could be to have a list similar to this, but available directly among the HN lists. Or even to notify a user when a Story is penalized on the Front Page, perhaps indicating the number of flags and/or the reason, for example.
Feel free to skip this part or click to expand
A friend of mine posted two Stories on Hacker News related to OnnxStream (31 days apart), the first related to SDXL Turbo support and the second related to TinyLlama and Mistral 7B support.
In the case of the first, the Story was among the first on the Front Page, until its title was changed from "Stable Diffusion Turbo on a Raspberry Pi Zero 2 generates an image in 29 minutes" to "OnnxStream: Stable Diffusion XL 1.0 Base on a Raspberry Pi Zero 2". This effectively "killed" the Story. One user pointed out that the new title didn't reflect the spirit of the Story (thanks @practice9).
In the case of the second, the Story was in third place on the Front Page, less than an hour after the submission. In this case it was simply removed from the Front Page.
Having discovered this, perplexed, I sent an email to the moderator. @dang, who was very kind and quick in his response, explained to me that the Story had been flagged by users even without being explicitly [flagged], and that he could therefore only hypothesize the causes of the flag. His hypothesis was that (some?) users might be fed up with news related to LLMs.
While I have no reason to doubt Daniel's good faith, it's hard to believe that HN users would be tired of LLM-related news.
So I decided to develop a small console application to determine the frequency of this phenomenon (actually I was also motivated by the prospect of writing some C# code, after more than 2 years of complete abstinence). I subsequently discovered that there were no tools/websites that monitored this specific phenomenon and I therefore decided to make it public here.
Using the official HN API, the service fetches 90 Top Stories every minute and makes a comparison with the first 30 Top Stories (i.e. the Front Page) fetched the previous minute. It logs all missing Stories here. The assumption is that a Story cannot go from the top 30 to a position higher than 90 in a single minute, without having been explicitly removed. If a Story reappears on the Front Page, it is removed from this log. All Stories present in the second cache pool are excluded from the log. Title and URL are those from when the Story first appeared in the top 30. The number of points and comments and the rank are those from when the Story was removed from the Front Page. The ID points to the news.social-protocols.org page for that Story, which provides a graph of the Story's position on the Front Page over time.
- 39087538 #13 25 points 8 comments -> How to Win Friends and Influence People: The Sam Altman Edition
- 39088941 #10 8 points 7 comments -> Let Detroit Go Bankrupt (2008)
- 39087776 #28 33 points 41 comments -> HP's CEO spells it out: You're a 'bad investment' if you don't buy HP supplies
- 39089421 #23 67 points 25 comments -> CCP members threaten British public piano player [video]
- 39089599 #23 20 points 41 comments -> Ford's new 48-inch digital dashboard is a lot of Android for one car
- 39092116 #20 4 points 0 comments -> Secret Plan Against Germany
- 39093901 #18 8 points 2 comments -> Vacation Rental Software Coming After Airbnb
- 39094343 #11 -> Financial Markets Microstructure Introduction
- 39091819 #11 92 points 32 comments -> Show HN: Vx.dev – GitHub-Powered AI for effortless development
- 39096404 #15 25 points 41 comments -> MrBeast reveals he made $250k from X video
- 39094387 #23 26 points 41 comments -> Open Source Doesn't Require Providing Builds
- 39095738 #22 26 points 41 comments -> Sam Altman Says AI Using Too Much Energy Will Require Breakthrough Energy Source
- 39096892 #23 8 points 1 comments -> Supreme Court rules border agents can remove razor wire erected by Texas
- 39097655 #27 105 points 82 comments -> Trello leaked 15M email addresses
- 39102078 #10 21 points 13 comments -> Avoid Async Rust at All Cost
- 39103328 #20 11 points 4 comments -> Sex differences in work preferences among gifted men and women
- 39103942 #11 13 points 16 comments -> Are electric vehicles cheaper to own? Maybe not
- 39104654 #13 7 points 0 comments -> 96% of U.S. temperature stations fail to meet what NOAA considers "acceptable" [pdf]
- 39103979 #7 4 points 0 comments -> Swedish startup Tillitis are looking for developers
- 39103146 #27 10 points 5 comments -> Hanging by a Strand: Worker dissent brews at an iconic New York bookstore (2020)
- 39105129 #22 5 points 1 comments -> Midjourney 6 Means the End for a Big Chunk of the Photo Industry
- 39105492 #12 13 points 2 comments -> An Oklahoma Anti-Porn Bill Could Ban Any Sort of Sexualized Photograph
- 39105568 #21 11 points 2 comments -> DB Cooper Case Could Close Soon Thanks to Particle Evidence
- 39105705 #18 -> FCC to End Broadband Discounts for the Poor After Republicans Undermine Program
- 39104535 #9 7 points 2 comments -> Meta-Learning Is All You Need
- 39103483 #20 -> Sex Differences in Work Preferences, Life Values, and Personal Views
- 39106904 #19 3 points 1 comments -> Them vs. US: Two Americas and How the Elite Is Out of Touch with Average America [pdf]
- 39106648 #3 10 points 1 comments -> ElevenLabs lands $80M from a16z and Sequoia – and becomes a unicorn
- 39107034 #3 5 points 0 comments -> The Variability Hypothesis
- 39109222 #11 81 points 3 comments -> Boeing internal whistleblower RE: MAX DOOR
- 39109513 #23 22 points 3 comments -> Mozilla's "Platform Tilt" shows how Firefox is harmed by Apple, Microsoft
- 39108226 #21 4 points 0 comments -> Hippy, capitalist, guru, grocer: Nicholas Saunders changed British food
- 39112659 #28 19 points 7 comments -> Farm owners bewildered after Apple Maps removes business and street from app
- 39113100 #28 8 points 0 comments -> Men are going to brutal boot camps to reclaim their masculinity
- 39112632 #18 46 points 12 comments -> Fix: Hong Kong is not in China
- 39113017 #19 27 points 9 comments -> New York City plans to wipe out $2B in medical debt for 500k residents
- 39090157 #22 -> What it takes to reroute the biggest cargo ships on a 4K mile detour
- 39113869 #24 12 points 5 comments -> Tesla plans to build new electric vehicles in mid-2025 -sources
- 39114728 #26 7 points 2 comments -> HP's CEO: We Brick Printers That Use Third-Party Ink Because Of, Hackers
- 39114528 #27 14 points 4 comments -> Nose wheel falls off Boeing 757 airliner waiting for takeoff
- 39113435 #30 13 points 4 comments -> WTF Ubiquiti
- 39114773 #24 39 points 41 comments -> Exxon throws a fit over shareholders exercising their rights
- 39116369 #1 107 points 89 comments -> 23andMe is reportedly turning the blame back on its customers
- 39117702 #13 7 points 3 comments -> Dangerous flash flooding is happening in Texas and Louisiana, more rain coming
- 39117672 #26 5 points 1 comments -> Customers discover 'fatal' design flaw in Tesla's Cybertruck
- 39118095 #27 4 points 1 comments -> Delta Air Lines Boeing 757 Lost Nose Wheel Before Takeoff, FAA Says
- 39118813 #21 8 points 3 comments -> Boeing 757 loses nose wheel while preparing for takeoff in Atlanta
- 39117810 #9 12 points 4 comments -> My Journey Submitting to Cran
- 39119286 #17 6 points 1 comments -> Russia's Wikipedia Shuts Down
- 39117468 #24 30 points 12 comments -> AMD Radeon RX 7600 XT Linux Performance
- 39119296 #27 3 points 0 comments -> Why the 155mm Shell Is One of the Most Wanted Objects Now [video]
- 39119009 #3 10 points 0 comments -> UK struggles to prove Houthis attacked its trade ships
- 39119252 #3 15 points 19 comments -> Offline Chat with Marcus Aurelius
- 39120875 #18 10 points 4 comments -> Jar Jar Binks: The greatest thing that ever happened to Star Wars
- 39121009 #30 6 points 2 comments -> America Is Planning to Withdraw from Syria
- 39121581 #25 5 points 0 comments -> Jon Stewart returning as part-time host of "The Daily Show" through the election
- 39121574 #11 37 points 14 comments -> Jon Stewart Returns to 'The Daily Show'
- 39121530 #23 10 points 1 comments -> This anime exposed a $28,000,000,000 sweatshop [video]
- 39121961 #6 9 points 0 comments -> The White House has a pharmacy – and it was a mess, a new investigation found
- 39088592 #24 57 points 11 comments -> The Evolution of Warfare and Weapons in Japan, 792-1392
- 39122778 #15 25 points 40 comments -> How many high school stars make it in the NBA?
- 39123762 #26 16 points 40 comments -> What Killed the Fight Scene?
- 39124972 #16 25 points 38 comments -> CA bill to require all new cars to prevent them from going 10mph over speedlimit
- 39124799 #15 -> Yes, the last 10 years have been worse for free speech
- 39126705 #22 42 points 17 comments -> NASA System Predicts Impact of a Small Asteroid over Germany
- 39131047 #4 12 points 1 comments -> The shared persuasion tactics of politics and startups
- 39131025 #30 22 points 9 comments -> Tesla shares tumble as analyst decries 'train wreck' investor call
- 39130652 #27 -> Israeli Settlers Dig Small Graves in Front of Palestinian School in Jericho
- 39131637 #17 9 points 1 comments -> NJ Bag Ban Followed By Increased Use Of Plastic, reusable bags used only once
- 39132091 #2 14 points 2 comments -> Why Is the Web So Monotonous? Google
- 39132073 #15 19 points 25 comments -> Do Elephants Have Souls?
- 39136137 #7 20 points 31 comments -> The Annual Cost of Technical Debt: $1.52T
- 39136960 #29 12 points 4 comments -> Why doesn't Apple show this warning for apps like Amazon, Uber, or Airbnb?
- 39135304 #29 28 points 39 comments -> Git commit messages are useless
- 39137432 #10 16 points 8 comments -> Figma to Start Charging Developers for View Access to Designs
- 39138130 #9 5 points 0 comments -> The Sexualized Messages Dress Codes Are Sending to Students
- 39138423 #25 13 points 3 comments -> Ring will no longer allow police to request users' doorbell camera footage
- 39140353 #24 7 points 0 comments -> The ADHD Exercise Solution (2023)
- 39141155 #1 9 points 5 comments -> About Apt-Get Install
- 39141328 #20 7 points 2 comments -> Kenneth Smith 'struggled for life' for 22 mins in Alabama nitrogen gas execution
- 39142094 #1 16 points 3 comments -> ICJ orders Israel to stop genocide in Gaza
- 39143228 #15 10 points 0 comments -> Expected CO₂ levels in 2024 threaten 1.5°C warming limit
- 39143204 #13 -> We Need Your Email Address
- 39143310 #20 4 points 4 comments -> Tesla's in Serious Trouble
- 39142985 #6 5 points 1 comments -> How to Build a Simple Sentiment Analyzer Using Hugging Face Transformer
- 39143509 #10 7 points 2 comments -> Big Five personality traits (a.k.a. "OCEAN model")
- 39143113 #28 24 points 6 comments -> Apple's new extortion regime to keep big app makers
- 39140135 #19 19 points 40 comments -> My heat pump: a personal story about a broken heating industry
- 39142075 #20 31 points 5 comments -> Everybody's aware that Google will start enforcing DMARC Feb 1st, right?
- 39144693 #21 -> Trolls have flooded X with graphic Taylor Swift AI fakes
- 39144886 #22 6 points 0 comments -> Far right extremists head to Texas border
- 39144974 #23 9 points 2 comments -> An 'Official Organization' on X Is Just Openly Glorifying Hitler Now
- 39143194 #15 8 points 2 comments -> North Korean Hackers Employ Generative AI for Cyberattacks
- 39144366 #24 12 points 0 comments -> Poor code quality due to AI assistants GitHub Copilot and ChatGPT
- 39143033 #28 8 points 2 comments -> Meta tool to block nude images in teens' private messages
- 39145229 #24 21 points 4 comments -> Stunned devs left scrambling for livelihoods in wake of layoff bloodbath
- 39144898 #26 33 points 15 comments -> Ukraine: Hack wiped 2 petabytes of data from Russian research center
- 39146177 #24 5 points 4 comments -> The real 30 under 30 imo you have never heard of
- 39146834 #12 55 points 41 comments -> Apple to EU, Drop Dead
- 39145632 #22 23 points 40 comments -> We've Forgotten How to Use Computers
- 39146788 #30 10 points 2 comments -> Tech layoffs balloon in Jan. as rally lifts Alphabet, Meta, Microsoft to records
- 39147669 #18 5 points 1 comments -> Pregnancies from rape occurring in abortion-ban states
- 39144867 #12 31 points 15 comments -> The Bad Economics of Wtfhappenedin1971
- 39148266 #21 11 points 7 comments -> 'Horizon IT system was 100% reliable'
- 39150283 #10 3 points 1 comments -> The Right It: Why So Many Ideas Fail and How to Make Sure Yours Succeed
- 39149036 #24 24 points 40 comments -> Netflix Hammers the Last Nail into Linear TV's Coffin
- 39151084 #15 44 points 17 comments -> Apple's plan to allow browser competition dubbed unworkable
- 39152804 #20 6 points 0 comments -> Blue Screen, SciFi novel about a hacker recruited by AI to take over the world
- 39153495 #25 6 points 0 comments -> Apple redecorates iPhone prison to appease EU regulators
- 39154444 #18 -> ChatGPT clone in 30 minutes on AWS Kubernetes
- 39155348 #16 -> Abortion investigations causing women 'life-changing harm', says UK expert
- 39155594 #27 3 points 1 comments -> California signs cursive writing into law
- 39155805 #26 5 points 0 comments -> CS University Lectures (Dr. Daniel Page)
- 39155627 #30 10 points 0 comments -> Apple's Plans for the DMA in the European Union
- 39157015 #16 -> Record number of Americans are homeless amid nationwide surge in rent
- 39160240 #29 10 points 2 comments -> The indie web
- 39160571 #28 17 points 1 comments -> Unrwa Ties to Oct. 7 Massacre Exposed – US Suspending Funding
- 39160421 #28 36 points 1 comments -> Microsoft explains how Russian hackers spied on its executives
- 39161940 #26 7 points 2 comments -> Garry Tan, tech CEO, wishes death upon San Francisco politicians
- 39162228 #7 8 points 5 comments -> The theory that consciousness is a quantum system gains support
- 39166525 #24 13 points 3 comments -> 'How to greenwash': propane industry tries to rebrand fuel as renewable
- 39166643 #19 25 points 41 comments -> Apple and Goldman Sachs: A timeline of the messy partnership that will soon fall
- 39168914 #12 -> Tech Layoffs Not Tied to Economic Struggles, but AI Investments
- 39169927 #26 7 points 2 comments -> On a Tesla: Don't
- 39170054 #3 15 points 8 comments -> US State Sales Tax Rates Chart
- 39169754 #20 13 points 43 comments -> What makes switching to GNU Linux almost impossible for many?
- 39167219 #26 12 points 3 comments -> Just
- 39166781 #25 37 points 30 comments -> Don't Shave That Yak (2005)
- 39169676 #11 25 points 40 comments -> Navy again lowers requirements as it struggles to meet recruitment goals
- 39171466 #25 9 points 6 comments -> Three US troops killed in drone attack in Jordan, more than 30 injured
- 39172772 #12 21 points 40 comments -> Passenger flight flying over Pacific reaches 822 MPH in jet stream
- 39173042 #18 16 points 6 comments -> Google Crimes
- 39174577 #4 17 points 13 comments -> Several Truths Regarding Success
- 39175675 #12 20 points 15 comments -> New tires every 7k miles? Electric cars save gas; tire wear shocks some drivers
- 39176382 #26 4 points 0 comments -> The Intellectual Rot of the Industrially Necessary University
- 39158254 #16 58 points 39 comments -> The Psychology of Apple Packaging
- 39177959 #14 26 points 36 comments -> Lubricate Your Keyholes
- 39178116 #13 2 points 0 comments -> VA_OPT Minutiae
- 39179125 #16 15 points 40 comments -> How the U.S. Government Could Lower Food Prices for Everyone
- 39178847 #27 48 points 4 comments -> Amazon drops $1.4B deal to buy iRobot after EU veto reports
- 39181217 #27 5 points 1 comments -> BeOS, the PC operating system that tried to challenge Windows and Mac
- 39181042 #11 20 points 7 comments -> Metal guitar skills linked to intrasexual competition, but not mating success
- 39181473 #16 22 points 41 comments -> There's No Good Reason to Buy a Carbon Bike
- 39180537 #17 15 points 6 comments -> Beliefs That Kill Birth Rates
- 39182122 #30 11 points 2 comments -> Matthias Wandel's YouTube channel got hacked [video]
- 39180898 #6 122 points 77 comments -> Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, ordered to liquidate
- 39182335 #9 -> Negligence by experts in the early response to Covid-19
- 39182294 #27 19 points 21 comments -> Walmart Store Managers Can Make Up to $400k
- 39179929 #27 62 points 38 comments -> Microsoft stole my Chrome tabs, and it wants yours, too
- 39182829 #18 6 points 3 comments -> Show HN: Submit your startup in 150 directories in 5 min
- 39183452 #25 13 points 0 comments -> Covid-19: Negligence by Experts
- 39183799 #4 18 points 1 comments -> Beliefs that kill birth rates
- 39184451 #5 12 points 4 comments -> The FAA's Hiring Scandal: A Quick Overview
- 39184363 #22 8 points 3 comments -> It looks like AI will kill Quantum Computing
- 39184181 #20 24 points 3 comments -> Deus Ex title killed after Embracer Group's cuts at Eidos
- 39184007 #21 28 points 21 comments -> IBM to Managers: Move Near an Office or Leave Company
- 39185267 #28 3 points 0 comments -> How about I get you a calculator instead
- 39185259 #23 6 points 0 comments -> To protect kids, California might require chronological feeds on social media
- 39185308 #23 13 points 1 comments -> Tesla's Recall Fix for Autopilot Irritates Drivers, Disappoints Safety Advocates
- 39189590 #13 17 points 30 comments -> Show HN: I made a site that lets you punish yourself
- 39189904 #14 6 points 3 comments -> Show HN: Understand your ideal customers without running 100 interviews
- 39193004 #24 15 points 3 comments -> Putin Isn't Hitler, He's Mussolini–and Ukraine Is His Abyssinia
- 39193096 #30 11 points 6 comments -> AI Companies and Advocates Are Becoming More Cult-Like
- 39193676 #30 5 points 0 comments -> Microsoft Edge is apparently usurping Chrome on people's PCs
- 39194269 #18 34 points 19 comments -> Rent has never been less affordable, especially for the middle class
- 39197770 #11 7 points 0 comments -> For 26 Years, Toforest Johnson Has Been on Death Row for Crime He Did Not Commit
- 39197495 #4 7 points 1 comments -> Here is Why You Must be INSANE to buy an RV These Days
- 39198438 #14 9 points 4 comments -> Framework DIY 13 Gen AMD Review
- 39198462 #13 74 points 59 comments -> Instagram Threads triples downloads in December, reaching top; X falls to #36
- 39199559 #16 12 points 0 comments -> Austin Gave Poor Families a Basic Income. It Changed Their Lives
- 39200226 #5 4 points 5 comments -> How to Find Hidden Cameras in Your Airbnb
- 39200511 #10 -> It turns out the six-feet social-distancing rule had no scientific basis
- 39199459 #18 41 points 41 comments -> We Must Call Time Out on TikTok
- 39201317 #15 298 points 227 comments -> Microsoft Edge ignores user wishes, slurps tabs from Chrome without permission
- 39203106 #17 76 points 72 comments -> Japan will no longer require floppy disks for submitting some official documents
- 39201224 #22 137 points 7 comments -> Microsoft Edge now steals your data from Google Chrome after an update
- 39203147 #19 13 points 3 comments -> The promise and challenges of crypto and AI applications
- 39207077 #29 6 points 1 comments -> Stochastic Terrorism
- 39206959 #28 14 points 2 comments -> A plan to save democracy by ending homelessness, reducing the prison population
- 39207475 #9 6 points 1 comments -> Biogen Abandons Its Controversial Alzheimer's Drug Aduhelm
- 39173329 #17 16 points 8 comments -> No one is "non-technical" (2022)
- 39207832 #8 11 points 6 comments -> In the Shadow of Silicon Valley: Losing San Francisco
- 39208326 #25 6 points 0 comments -> Wikipedian Osama Khalid celebrated his 30th birthday in jail
- 39209111 #23 19 points 4 comments -> Sen Wyden Reintroduces Legislation That Would Actually Help Be Kids Safer Online
- 39209642 #9 7 points 1 comments -> Innovating S3 Bucket Retrieval: LangChain Community S3 Loaders with OpenAI API
- 39209607 #25 43 points 10 comments -> A roadmap and appeal for help from The Matrix.org Foundation
- 39212257 #30 13 points 1 comments -> Photoshop's "generative expand" tool may have expanded bust and exposed midriff
- 39212819 #26 6 points 0 comments -> Garry Tan's Tupac Reference Goes Wrong
- 39212766 #24 30 points 3 comments -> How Boeing Put Profits over Planes
- 39214844 #18 4 points 0 comments -> War destroyed Gaza's neighbourhoods – visual investigation
- 39175137 #20 7 points 5 comments -> String Prism
- 39215069 #24 4 points 0 comments -> UK fertility treatment comparison tool featuring IVF data launched
- 39213992 #30 26 points 41 comments -> UK Wind Farms Are Overstating Their Output
- 39215302 #4 4 points 1 comments -> InstaPython – Instant custom Python scripts on-demand
- 39215270 #13 3 points 2 comments -> What is an integration platform and how to integrate APIs correctly?
- 39215142 #25 19 points 40 comments -> Think of your home as (small) profitable power plant
- 39215913 #14 11 points 4 comments -> Why are Russian covert actions so easily unmasked?
- 39216249 #8 6 points 0 comments -> US Court Concludes Plausible Genocide, Dismissies Case on Jurisdictional Grounds
- 39216149 #8 26 points 13 comments -> AI-related companies lost $190B in stock market value
- 39215365 #17 7 points 4 comments -> Show HN: Don't Do It Bro: porn addiction peer-support
- 39216761 #25 -> This is the world’s rarest passport
- 39217757 #19 19 points 14 comments -> It's Fair to Describe Schizophrenia as Probably Mostly Genetic
- 39218410 #23 7 points 1 comments -> Nine Ugly Truths about Copyright and five predictions about its future
- 39217440 #5 37 points 20 comments -> Quadratic – Open-Source Spreadsheet Is Now Multiplayer
- 39218554 #10 8 points 0 comments -> Study finds emerging gender divide in young people's attitudes
- 39218803 #30 -> Google Bard keeps generating images containing girls
- 39219073 #26 9 points 5 comments -> Why Men Are Drifting to the Far Right
- 39216790 #25 43 points 40 comments -> What Makes for 'Good' Mathematics?
- 39219371 #27 22 points 40 comments -> Watch a 7k-LB Rivian R1T Destroy a Guardrail in Eyebrow-Raising Test
- 39219349 #1 102 points 1 comments -> A SQLite extension that brings column-oriented tables to SQLite
- 39219568 #9 60 points 49 comments -> Starlink's Laser System Is Beaming 42 Petabytes of Data per Day
- 39221040 #9 9 points 0 comments -> "No way to prevent this" say users of only language where this regularly happens
- 39219553 #30 -> Math Built the Modern World
- 39221661 #16 9 points 2 comments -> Show HN: The Super Programmer – A colorful introduction to engineering
- 39224292 #26 9 points 2 comments -> Utah Bans DEI Programs, Joining Other States
- 39225118 #30 3 points 2 comments -> So Many Problems Continue to Plague the EV Industry
- 39226442 #4 22 points 14 comments -> Five tube stations now have new circular tube maps
- 39227295 #21 7 points 0 comments -> Breathing 101
- 39228556 #5 8 points 3 comments -> Total nonfarm payroll employment rose by 353,000 in January
- 39228534 #6 8 points 0 comments -> U.S. economy adds whopping 353,000 jobs in January as labor market heats up
- 39228879 #21 11 points 5 comments -> The Rise of the American Oligarchy