blockchain blockchain-technology smart-contracts solidity solidity-security

Solidity Security Audit Checklist

This repository provides a comprehensive checklist and a set of tools to help you audit the security of Solidity smart contracts. It aims to assist developers, auditors, and security researchers in identifying common vulnerabilities and best practices when reviewing smart contract code.

The checklist covers various aspects of smart contract security, including:

Reentrancy vulnerabilities
Integer overflow/underflow
Unchecked external calls
Access control issues
Input validation and sanitization
Randomness and timestamp dependence
Gas optimization

In addition to the checklist, the repository includes:

Code snippets demonstrating vulnerabilities and their fixes
Recommendations for automated security analysis tools
Step-by-step usage instructions
Real-world case studies and lessons learned
Community engagement and discussion platform
Additional resources for smart contract security

Whether you're a developer looking to ensure the security of your smart contracts or an auditor conducting a thorough security review, this repository provides a structured and comprehensive approach to identifying and mitigating potential vulnerabilities.

Join our community, contribute your own findings and experiences, and together, let's enhance the security of the Solidity smart contract ecosystem!

Security Audit Checklist

This section provides a comprehensive checklist categorized by vulnerability types, explaining the importance of each check and the associated risks.

Progress Tracker

Reentrancy Vulnerabilities

Reentrancy vulnerabilities occur when external contracts are allowed to make recursive calls back into the vulnerable contract before the original transaction is completed. This can lead to unexpected behavior and the draining of funds.

Check for untrusted external contract calls
Ensure state updates happen before external calls
Use reentrancy guards or checks-effects-interactions pattern

Integer Overflow/Underflow

Integer overflow and underflow vulnerabilities happen when arithmetic operations result in a value that is outside the range of the integer type. This can lead to incorrect calculations and unexpected behavior.

Use SafeMath or similar libraries for arithmetic operations
Validate input values to prevent unexpected overflows/underflows

Unchecked External Calls

Unchecked external calls can lead to failures if the external contract reverts or runs out of gas. It's important to handle these situations gracefully.

Check the return value of external calls
Handle failures gracefully and avoid assumptions about external contract behavior

Access Control

Access control vulnerabilities arise when unauthorized users can access sensitive functions or modify critical state variables.

Implement proper access control mechanisms for sensitive functions
Use modifiers to restrict access based on roles or permissions
Avoid using tx.origin for authorization

Input Validation and Sanitization

Lack of proper input validation and sanitization can allow attackers to manipulate contract behavior or exploit vulnerabilities.

Validate and sanitize all user inputs
Enforce proper constraints on input values
Use safe string manipulation techniques

Randomness

Generating true randomness is challenging in blockchain environments due to the deterministic nature of smart contracts. Improper use of randomness can lead to predictable outcomes and vulnerabilities.

Do not rely on block hash, timestamp, or other blockchain data for randomness
Use secure and audited random number generation techniques, such as commit-reveal schemes or oracles

Timestamp Dependence

Relying on block timestamps for critical logic can be problematic due to the potential manipulation of timestamps by miners.

Avoid using block timestamps for critical logic
If timestamps are used, be aware of the limitations and potential vulnerabilities

Gas Optimization

Inefficient gas usage can lead to high transaction costs and potential out-of-gas exceptions.

Optimize gas usage to prevent out-of-gas exceptions
Minimize storage reads and writes
Use efficient data structures and algorithms

Vulnerability Code Snippets

This section provides well-commented code snippets demonstrating vulnerabilities and their fixes. Each code snippet includes a description of the vulnerability, its potential impact, and the recommended mitigation technique.

Reentrancy Vulnerability Example

// Vulnerable contract
contract VulnerableContract {
    mapping(address => uint) public balances;

    function withdraw() public {
        uint amount = balances[msg.sender];
        (bool success, ) = msg.sender.call.value(amount)("");
        require(success, "Transfer failed.");
        balances[msg.sender] = 0;
    }
}

// Fixed contract
contract FixedContract {
    mapping(address => uint) public balances;

    function withdraw() public {
        uint amount = balances[msg.sender];
        balances[msg.sender] = 0;
        (bool success, ) = msg.sender.call.value(amount)("");
        require(success, "Transfer failed.");
    }
}

In the vulnerable contract, the external call is made before updating the balance, allowing for reentrancy. The fixed contract updates the balance before making the external call, preventing reentrancy.

Integer Overflow Example

// Vulnerable contract
contract VulnerableContract {
    uint public balance;

    function deposit(uint amount) public {
        balance += amount;
    }
}

// Fixed contract
contract FixedContract {
    using SafeMath for uint;

    uint public balance;

    function deposit(uint amount) public {
        balance = balance.add(amount);
    }
}

The vulnerable contract is susceptible to integer overflow, while the fixed contract uses the SafeMath library to prevent overflow.

Automated Security Analysis Tools

This section lists and describes various automated tools that can aid in security analysis, including their setup instructions, expected output, and result interpretation guidelines.

Static Analysis Tools

Slither: Slither is a Solidity static analysis framework that detects vulnerabilities, suggests optimizations, and provides a suite of tools for smart contract analysis.
Mythril: Mythril is a security analysis tool that uses symbolic execution to detect vulnerabilities in smart contracts.
Securify: Securify is a security scanner for Ethereum smart contracts that analyzes contracts for vulnerabilities and provides security insights.

Linters

Solhint: Solhint is a linter for Solidity that provides security, style, and best practice rules for smart contract development.
Ethlint: Ethlint is a linter for Solidity that identifies security vulnerabilities, coding style issues, and best practice violations.

Fuzzing Tools

Echidna: Echidna is a smart contract fuzzer that generates random transactions to test smart contracts for vulnerabilities and property violations.
Harvey: Harvey is a fuzzer for Solidity smart contracts that uses coverage-guided techniques to identify vulnerabilities.

Symbolic Execution Tools

Manticore: Manticore is a symbolic execution tool for analyzing smart contracts and identifying vulnerabilities.
Mythril (also listed in Static Analysis Tools): Mythril combines symbolic execution with taint analysis and control flow checking to detect a wide range of vulnerabilities.

Tool Comparison

For a quick and comprehensive static analysis, use Slither or Securify.
For in-depth analysis and detecting complex vulnerabilities, use Mythril or Manticore.
For linting and style checking, use Solhint or Ethlint.
For testing edge cases and finding property violations, use Echidna or Harvey.

It's recommended to use a combination of tools for a thorough security audit.

Usage Instructions

This section provides a step-by-step guide on how to effectively use the provided resources, from setting up the environment to reporting findings.

Setting Up the Environment

Install Node.js and npm
Clone this repository: git clone https://github.com/iAnonymous3000/solidity-security-audit-checklist.git
Install the required dependencies: npm install

Reviewing the Checklist

Familiarize yourself with the Security Audit Checklist
Use the checklist as a reference during your manual code review process
Check off the items in the Progress Tracker as you complete each section

Running Automated Tools

Choose the appropriate automated tools based on your needs and the Tool Comparison guidance
Follow the setup instructions provided for each tool
Run the tools against your smart contract code
Analyze the tool output and interpret the results

Manual Code Review

Review the code line by line, keeping the checklist items in mind
Refer to the Vulnerability Code Snippets for examples of vulnerabilities and their fixes
Document any identified vulnerabilities or potential issues

Reporting Findings

Compile a comprehensive report detailing your findings
Include the identified vulnerabilities, their potential impact, and recommended remediation steps
Provide the report to the relevant stakeholders for review and action

Case Studies

This section includes real-world examples and case studies from past audits to provide practical insights into smart contract vulnerabilities and their consequences.

The DAO Hack

The DAO hack was a famous exploit that resulted in the theft of approximately $50 million worth of Ether. The attacker exploited a reentrancy vulnerability in The DAO's smart contract, allowing them to repeatedly withdraw funds before the contract could update its balance.

Lessons learned:

Reentrancy vulnerabilities can have severe consequences
Proper access control and state updates are crucial
Thorough testing and auditing are essential before deploying contracts

Parity Multisig Wallet Hack

The Parity Multisig Wallet hack resulted in the freezing of over $30 million worth of Ether. The attacker exploited a vulnerability in the wallet's initialization function, allowing them to take control of the contract and prevent further access to the funds.

Lessons learned:

Proper initialization and access control are critical
Simplicity and modularity can reduce the attack surface
Regular audits and updates are necessary to address potential vulnerabilities

Community Engagement

This section encourages users to share their audit experiences, discuss challenges they encountered, and how they resolved them. It provides a forum or discussion platform where users can interact and learn from each other. Users are encouraged to contribute their own case studies and lessons learned.

Participate in discussions on our GitHub Discussions page
Contribute your own case studies and lessons learned by submitting a pull request

Security Practices Beyond Solidity

This section provides a holistic view of smart contract security by including resources and best practices for operational security, multi-sig wallets, and smart contract upgradeability patterns.

Additional Resources

This section provides links to external resources, articles, and guides for further learning about smart contract security.

Contributing

We welcome contributions from the community to help improve and expand this repository. If you have suggestions for additional checklist items, code snippets, or tools, please follow the contribution guidelines below.

Contribution Guidelines

Fork the repository and create a new branch for your contributions
Ensure your code adheres to the existing style and formatting conventions
Include clear and concise documentation for any new additions
Submit a pull request with a detailed description of your changes

Submitting Changes

Fork the repository and create a new branch: git checkout -b my-feature-branch
Make your changes and commit them: git commit -m 'Add new feature'
Push your changes to your forked repository: git push origin my-feature-branch
Open a pull request against the main repository

Regular Updates

This repository is regularly updated to keep up with the latest security best practices and emerging vulnerabilities. Users are encouraged to watch the repository for updates and check back for the latest versions.

We hope this repository serves as a comprehensive guide and toolset for auditing the security of your Solidity smart contracts. Remember to stay vigilant, keep your knowledge up-to-date, and always prioritize security in your smart contract development process. Happy auditing!

About