VP9 best settings for converting animated gif-like png sequence to a video

The goal of this page is to list results I captured while looking for the VP9 video encoder best settings for converting a gif-like animated drawing based on a png sequence to a video. As gif is a lossless image format, the goal here is not to get the smallest video file, but more the best compromise between the quality (prio 1), the file size (prio 2) and the encoding time (prio 3).

Note The input png sequence images have been captured thanks to the Python Turtle Country Flags 🐍 🐢 from here.

Table of contents

Quick outcomes without wasting time reading more (TLDR) 😄
Extra notes
Visual results
Detailed results
Related documentations
How to use the scripts
How to update input files
APNG or WebP instead of vp9 ?
Wrap up
Any questions or comments are welcome 🐦

Quick outcomes without wasting time reading more (TLDR) 😄

🏅 Forget gif format, use instead webm vp9 video format. You may think about using apng or webp image formats but results are not as good as vp9 for both quality and file size.
🥇 Best command that is perfect in most cases ✔️:

ffmpeg -framerate my_fps_value -pattern_type glob -i '*.png' -c:v libvpx-vp9 output.webm

🥈 Best command for the best quality 🌈 (file size close to 2. but slower encoding in 2-pass):

# ffmpeg vp9 encode lossless speed 0 2-pass
ffmpeg -framerate my_fps_value -y -i '*.png' -pass 1 -c:v libvpx-vp9 -lossless 1 -speed 0 -f webm /dev/null
ffmpeg -framerate my_fps_value    -i '*.png' -pass 2 -c:v libvpx-vp9 -lossless 1 -speed 0 output.webm

🥉 Best command for the smallest file size 💪 (quality is less good than 2. and 3. but acceptable) :

# ffmpeg vp9 encode quality good speed 0 crf 10
ffmpeg -framerate my_fps_value -pattern_type glob -i '*.png' -c:v libvpx-vp9 -quality good -speed 0 -crf 10 output.webm

Extra notes

Note HTML code for using a video as a gif animation image:

<video autoplay loop muted playsinline title="your alternate text">
  <source src="your_file.webm" type="video/webm">
</video>

Note ffmpeg input file syntax: Hereafter examples that may help you using the ffmpeg syntax (ffmpeg related documentation):

export fps=20
ffmpeg -framerate $fps -i your_files_%04d.png output.webm  # The printf way
ffmpeg -framerate $fps -pattern_type glob -i '*.png' output.webm  # The wildcad way

Note I added this above note because it took me times to understand the ffmpeg syntax and there are still odd things that still does not work on my side like. For instance, you can not do export myfile="'*.png'" and use $myfile instead of *.png because you will have an No such file or directory error message :-(

Visual results


Big gif file gifsicle_o3_colors_256.gif (730,476 bytes)	perfect in most cases ✔️ ffmpeg_vp9_default.webm (294,570 bytes)
the best quality 🌈 ffmpeg_vp9_lossless_speed_0_2_pass.webm (297,484 bytes)	the smallest file size 💪 ffmpeg_vp9_quality_good_speed_0_cfr_10.webm (180,735 bytes)

Note ⚠️ Github does not support video in markdown files, even if it is with the <video> html tag :-(!!! If you want to better see the differences between the 3 winners, please open the related README.html.

Detailed results

Type	Size	%	Quality	Filename	sec	%
gif	2,288,891	213%	Perfect	imagemagick_default.gif	103,5	442%
gif	816,729	12%	Perfect	imagemagick_layers_optimize.gif	42,9	125%
gif	931,165	27%	Perfect	ezgif_lossy_200pc.gif ezgif online optimizer (lossy 200%)	na	na
gif	1,923,835	163%	Perfect	gifsicle_o1.gif	1,1	-94%
gif	1,099,891	51%	Perfect	gifsicle_o2.gif	1,3	-93%
gif	1,058,821	45%	Perfect	gifsicle_o3.gif	1,6	-92%
gif	730,476	100%	Perfect	gifsicle_o3_colors_256.gif	1,8	-90%
gif	1,865,002	155%	Bad	ffmpeg_default.gif	2,3	-88%
vp9	294,570	-60%	Good	ffmpeg_default.webm	19,1	100%
vp9	290,069	-60%	Good	ffmpeg_default_2_pass.webm	43,1	126%
vp9	294,570	-60% ✔️	Good ✔️	ffmpeg_vp9_default.webm	19,1	0%
vp9	290,069	-60%	Good	ffmpeg_vp9_default_2_pass.webm	43,1	126%
vp9	440,770	-40%	Perfect	ffmpeg_vp9_lossless.webm	31,7	66%
vp9	315,926	-57%	Perfect	ffmpeg_vp9_lossless_2_pass.webm	41,9	119%
vp9	342,858	-53%	Perfect	ffmpeg_vp9_lossless_speed_0.webm	42,2	121%
vp9	297,484	-59%	Perfect 🌈	ffmpeg_vp9_lossless_speed_0_2_pass.webm	55,5	191%
vp9	289,051	-60%	Good	ffmpeg_vp9_quality_good_speed_0.webm	27,7	45%
vp9	286,179	-61%	Good	ffmpeg_vp9_quality_good_speed_0_2_pass.webm	60,2	215%
vp9	393,069	-46%	Medium	ffmpeg_vp9_quality_good_speed_5.webm	14,2	-26%
vp9	343,217	-53%	Medium	ffmpeg_vp9_quality_good_speed_5_2_pass.webm	32,2	68%
vp9	289,051	-60%	Good	ffmpeg_vp9_quality_good_speed_0_cfr_0.webm	27,8	45%
vp9	234,628	-68%	Good	ffmpeg_vp9_quality_good_speed_0_cfr_0_2_pass.webm	38,5	101%
vp9	180,735	-75% 💪	Medium	ffmpeg_vp9_quality_good_speed_0_cfr_10.webm	24,3	27%
vp9	211,367	-71%	Medium	ffmpeg_vp9_quality_good_speed_0_cfr_10_2_pass.webm	37,5	96%
vp9	91,638	-87%	Low	ffmpeg_vp9_quality_good_speed_0_cfr_63.webm	23,2	21%
vp9	85,450	-88%	Low	ffmpeg_vp9_quality_good_speed_0_cfr_63_2_pass.webm	32,5	70%

Note All results are in results.ods file.

Few comments

vp9 -quality best is not recommended in the vp9 documentation, -quality realtime is for steaming, here only -quality good is usefull then.
ffmpeg by default uses vp9 on my linux configuration. If you have a doubt, please add -c:v libvpx-vp9.
we may play more with -speed x too but not really necessary here as the animation is very simple and short. Moreover, gif images are lossless so better to use -speed 0 to get the best quality.
gifsicle works only on gif file as input.
ezgif.com online gif optimizer has been evaluated too but results are lower than gifsicle -O3.

Warnings

⚠️ ffmpeg gif output is not correct! Maybe I should try the latest ffmpeg version...
⚠️ Measured times depend on my hw configuration, your results will differ probably.
⚠️ If it works in my case, it does not necessarily mean that it will work in all your cases, even if I sincerely think that my advices remain valid in many cases, anyway, hope it helps 😄.

How to use the scripts

The encode_test.sh script contains all the different commands, that may help you if you are looking for details.

./encode_test.sh -h
./encode_test.sh 2>&1 | tee `date +"%F_%Hh%Mm%Ss"`.log

How to update input files

Simply update the content of the input directory with your png files.

Note You can also use -i dirname parameter to use to preferred directory.

You can update the input.7z file with the input directory content thanks to following commands:

rm input.7z
7z a input.7z input

APNG or WebP instead of vp9 ?

Before selecting vp9, I have considered both apng and webp image formats. But results are clearly not (maybe not yet) as good as vp9 ones for both quality (lossless) and filesize (lossy).

APNG

time gif2apng ${output}/imagemagick_default.gif -o ${output}/gif2apng_default.png

WebP

export t=`echo "1000/$fps" | bc`
time img2webp -loop 0 -d $t             ${input}/*.png -o ${output}/img2webp_default.webp
time img2webp -loop 0 -d $t -lossless   ${input}/*.png -o ${output}/img2webp_lossless.webp
time img2webp -loop 0 -d $t -min_size   ${input}/*.png -o ${output}/img2webp_min_size.webp
time img2webp -loop 0 -d $t -mixed      ${input}/*.png -o ${output}/img2webp_mixed.webp
time img2webp -loop 0 -d $t -mixed -m 6 ${input}/*.png -o ${output}/img2webp_mixed_m6.webp

Documentations

WebP: img2webp
APNG: gif2apng or ezgif online apng

Wrap up

We may have better results using different vp9 encoder parameters...

Any questions or comments are welcome 🐦

If you have any comments or questions, feel free to send me an email at coolcornucopia@outlook.com 📧.

Peace

coolcornucopia 😄

coolcornucopia / vp9-best-settings-for-converting-gif-animated-drawing-to-video