Flutter for Apple TV

A modification of the Flutter engine + test application to demonstrate that Flutter applications run on Apple TV

This project (and Liberty Global repositories referred to) are for testing purposes only!

Flutter and the related logo are trademarks of Google LLC We are not endorsed by or affiliated with Google LLC.

Approach:

Engine:
- Use ios target to compile tvos target
  - It is possible to create a new tvos target, but this would have impact and more files would need to be changed and therefore require more effort to maintain Apple TV support in the engine
    - This can be done by modifiying the makefiles in the different projects
    - See 'real_tvos_target' branch (not finished!)
  - Instead of using ios SDK, tvos SDK is used
- Disable/replace code not supported by tvos SDK
- Added support for Apple TV remote
  - Swipe
    - Based on gesture recognizer & game controller
    - Created new channel to forward movement to application
    - Application translates movement to left, right, up & down
      - Handling this in the application allows the application to optimize the speed etc per screen / use-case
  - Remote keys:
    - Menu, play-pause, … are mapped to key codes
    - Menu key is mapped to “popRoute” function, but could be mapped to ‘back’ key
  - Keyboard input:
    - 1.26: Support for ios keyboard and no modifications needed.
    - In flutter 1.15/1.19/1.22 a subset of keys is mapped to "macos" and "Android" key codes
- Repositories modified
  - https://github.com/flutter/buildroot --> https://github.com/LibertyGlobal/flutter-tvos-buildroot
  - https://github.com/flutter/engine --> https://github.com/LibertyGlobal/flutter-tvos-engine
  - https://dart.googlesource.com/sdk --> https://github.com/LibertyGlobal/flutter-tvos-dart
  - https://skia.googlesource.com/skia --> https://github.com/LibertyGlobal/flutter-tvos-skia
  - Tested flutter engines:
    - 1.15, 1.19-candidate-4, 1.22-candidate.13, 1.26.0-17.6-pre, 2.0.4, 2.10.3, 3.3.10, 3.10.6
Framework
- No modifications in "flutter" tool (/framework)
- Platform tvos not supported, ios target cannot be used because without modifications it would the use wrong SDK(ios) to compile the application
Application
- Changes compared to ios application setup:
  - Modified main storyboard
  - Icon set for tvos
  - Custom script to compile application which replaces code_backend.sh in the “build phases” step. This script is based on scripts from the engine test application which only use tools from the engine. The normal script cannot be used because it used the standard “flutter” tool which does not support tvos.
- Copy generated resources from real ios app target. The test app target actually overwrites the ios build to use the resources.
- Change targets for application and pods to ‘tvos’ and set minimum OS version to 12.0

Known limitations

Not all pods will compile. ios target is used and some API's are not supported by tvos. E.g. WebView
No debugging capabilities
No Apple TV look and feel widgets, no integration of virtual keyboard, ...
Resource monitoring is not supported by tvos (using flutter tools)

Known Issues

When a debug version is installed on a simulator or Apple TV device, then the app will not load when selected on screen. It will only load from the xcode debugger. This is not an issue for release builds. This has most likely to do with the fact that the app is trying to connect to 127.0.0.1 which is not started because the flutter tools are not used.

Supported devices

Apple tvOS 12.0 or later

Workarounds

Disabled fork commands etc. in process_macos.cc
- This should not be needed and only be compiled for host
- dart-lang/sdk#39918 (comment)
Disabled fatal error in kernel_translation_helper.cc, still to be investigated what the root cause is

Setting up engine / development environment

Host compilation (macos) fails on system with 16Gb memory, no issues on 32Gb mac
- Added --no-lto flag, see flutter/flutter#57207
Based on instructions here: https://github.com/flutter/flutter/wiki/Setting-up-the-Engine-development-environment)
Create empty directory called engine for you local copy of the repository and cd into it. (some tools assume this folder name!)

Create a .gclient file in engine directory with the following contents:

solutions = [
  {
    "managed": False,
    "name": "src/flutter",
    "url": "git@github.com:LibertyGlobal/flutter-tvos-engine.git@3.10.6",
    "custom_deps": {},
    "deps_file": "DEPS",
    "safesync_url": "",
  },
]

Run gclient sync in engine directory
See flutter wiki for Java SKD and 'ant' dependencies
Install "flutter" version 3.10.6 (https://flutter.dev/docs/get-started/install/macos)

Compiling the engine

The script will build 5 targets for TVOS in the src/out folder:
- ios_debug_unopt, ios_debug_sim_unopt, ios_release, host_debug_unopt and host_release release
Note: Fectching all repositories and compiling the engine for Apple TV (all targets) requires at leaste 29Gb of free diskspace!
Run in /engine/src/ script sh ninja_build.sh (located in script folder, see ninja_build.sh)
- Add paramter clean for a full rebuild.
- Note: The --no-lto flag can be removed on host systems with minimum 32Gb
Based on: https://github.com/flutter/flutter/wiki/Compiling-the-engine. The problem with the order described on this wiki is that the generated files for the host point to the ios/tvos sdk instead of macos

Compiling application

1st build real ios target to make sure the resources(images, fonts, ...) are generated by the flutter tools and can be used for tvos
- Open ios/Runner.xcworkspace and set signing team and bundle identifier
- Run command: flutter build ios
Note: the application will regardless of the target, always be compiled to /build/ios/Release-iphoneos. The main reasone for this is that the resouces generated by the normal ios build are located here and are re-used.
- This means that if any of the resource will change, added or removed that normal ios build must be done first. In order to do this, the step below must be un done first!
Rename tvos folder to ios
- Flutter tools assume the folder name is ios. Flutter pub get will fail if the folder has a different name!
- Run command: sh scripts/switch_target.sh tvos
- (to switch back to ios: sh scripts/switch_target.sh ios)
Run command: flutter pub get
Go to ios folder
Install/get cocoa pods
- Run command: pod install
- Pods target is automatically corrected from ios to tvos in podfile post_install step
Set path to local compiled flutter engine in FLUTTER_LOCAL_ENGINE (src folder) enviroment variable
Copy flutter framework to pods
- Run command: sh ../scripts/copy_framework.sh debug_sim
- Copies debug simulator version. The correct version (debug, sim, release/archive) will be copied during app compilation
- Unfortunately this is a manual step, because the pods are compiled first as a dependency by xcode and there is no hook in the xcode build process before this to automatically copy the right frame work to be used based on the selected target
Open in ios folder Runner.xcworkspace
- In settings, set signing team and bundle identifier
- Set path to local compiled flutter engine in FLUTTER_LOCAL_ENGINE (src folder)
- e.g. FLUTTER_LOCAL_ENGINE = <your local path to flutter engine>/engine/src
- alternatively run: sed -i '' "s#FLUTTER_LOCAL_ENGINE[[:space:]]=[[:space:]].*;#FLUTTER_LOCAL_ENGINE = \"${FLUTTER_LOCAL_ENGINE}\";#g" Runner.xcodeproj/project.pbxproj
Build app for device debug, simulator or archive (see switching target below)

Common issues

Engine

3.3.10: in case compilation of libpng.pngread.o fails. Replace src/third_party/libpng/pngread.c with file pngread.c from patches folder

this only happens with newer compilers/SDK's

../../third_party/libpng/pngread.c:3455:26: error: variable 'row' set but not used [-Werror,-Wunused-but-set-variable]
         `png_bytep row = png_voidcast(png_bytep, display->first_row);

Application
- If compilation fails because of this reason:
```
Showing Recent Messages
Ignoring file /Users/../tvos-demo/ios/Flutter/Flutter.framework/Flutter, building for tvOS Simulator-x86\_64 but attempting to link with file built for tvOS-arm64
Undefined symbol: _OBJC_CLASS_$_FlutterError
Undefined symbol: _OBJC_CLASS_$_FlutterMethodChannel
Undefined symbol: _FlutterMethodNotImplemented
```
  - When switching between targetes (simulator <=> debug/release), then the correct framework must be copied / updated
  - This can be solved by copy the correct version of the framework to the flutter folder
    - sh scripts/copy_framework.sh <target> <path to local flutter engine>
    - Targets: debug, debug_sim, release
- Switching between targets: simulator(debug), debug (on Actual AppleTV device) & Release/archive
  - First "Clean build folder" in Xcode
  - Copy to be used framework (See above)
  - Build / Archive
- Distribution / Validation in Organizer fails
  - Check if both ios_deployment_target & MinimumOSVersion in the engine and app match. Both must be 12.0!
    - The info.plist file is copied from the engine to the flutter.framework folder and contains 12.0

Contributors

Jürgen Wölke, Prikshit Chahar, Andrei Lesnitsky
v2.0.4: Aleksandr Denisov, Oleksandr Prokhorenko, Maksim Nazaruk, Andrei Kulbeda
v2.10.3: Aleksandr Denisov, Maksim Nazaruk, Andrei Kulbeda
v3.3.10: Aleksandr Denisov, Andrei Kulbeda, Jürgen Wölke v3.10.6: Eldar Pikunov, Jürgen Wölke

LibertyGlobal / flutter-tvos-demo