Electric-Coin-Company / tfl-book

A Trailing Finality Layer book for a proposed Zcash protocol change.

tfl-book

The Zcash Trailing Finality Layer design book.

This repository is the source text and rendering configuration for the book. To read the book, use the link above.

The mdbook tool renders the contents into a pretty format from markdown based source code

Github CI

There are two github CI workflows:

• merge-acceptance.yaml: triggers on pull_request to check that mdbook build succeeds and there aren't dangling md files (e.g. you remove an entry in SUMMARY.md but forget to rm the file.)
• render-site.yaml: triggers on push to main to render the site to https://electric-coin-company.github.io/tfl-book/
  • Warning: this workflow relies on full read/write access to the gh-pages branch. Don't mess with that branch unless you're very confident in the impacts.

git-hooks

There is a directory git-hooks that we advocate all contributors use.

Use this command to enable it:

git config --local core.hooksPath git-hooks

Prerequisites

Note: Nix users can rely on flake.nix which packages the final rendered HTML into <prefix>/share/doc/tfl-book. Users can install this via nix profile install 'github:Electric-Coin-Company/tfl-book', or to build the local version nix build.

Rust prerequisites

• cargo install mdbook
• cargo install mdbook-graphviz
• cargo install mdbook-katex
• cargo install mdbook-linkcheck

Other prerequisites

• graphviz - on debian-like: sudo apt install graphviz

Rendering

• mdbook build

Release Process

Releases are defined as distinct revisions that embody a consistent set of changes from the prior releases, identified by a version with XXX.YYY.ZZZ format. Releases serve a few purposes. They:

• ensure that readers can better notice changes or updates between readings or in discussions with others,
• signify that the authors have converged after a period of editing onto a coherent integrated result,
• signify an approximate maturity of the design, based on the version number, and
• serve as a natural milestone for announcements on design updates.

Versioning Schema

The versioning scheme isn't precise and roughly follows this rubrik:

When a version X.Y.Z increments, the scope of change since the prior release is implied by the new version:

• <X+1>.0.0 - This release represents a complete, well analyzed design which the authors believe could be a suitable candidate for Zcash (or other crypto networks) to productionize by developing conforming implementations that activate in production.
• X.<Y+1>.0 - This release introduces or changes substantial design decisions or analyses, or it changes the presentation (such as the order or content of chapters) significantly. A reader of only the prior release may be missing essential details in understanding this new release.
• X.Y.<Z+1> - This release improves the wording, layout, rendering, or other content in a manner that doesn't rise to the threshold of the previous case.

Release Process

To create a new release:

1. Decide that the main branch is in a coherent state without likely sources of confusion or self-inconsistency.
2. Decide the new release's version as in Versioning Schema above.
3. Create a release branch named release-<NEW VERSION>.
4. Update the release branch with these changes:

• book.toml: Modify the title to end with vX.Y.Z. This ensures the version is visible to readers on all pages.
• src/version-history.md: Introduce a new heading ## X.Y.Z - <RELEASE TITLE> above all prior entries (i.e. reverse chronologically).
  • The RELEASE TITLE should be a short-hand title capturing the primary change of the release.
  • The release body should always begin with a link titled Issue Tracking that navigates to the GitHub milestone page of completed issues in this release.
  • The rest of the release body should be a one- to three-sentence summary of changes. Readers who need more detail can follow issue tracking.
• src/introduction.md: The first paragraph says This is <VERSION LINK> of the book. Update that link to point to the new release's entry in src/version-history.md.

5. Submit those changes for GitHub pull-request review, resolve any blocking concerns, then merge to the main branch. Note: This step will render the release.
6. Create a git tag on the git commit that merges into main: git tag vX.Y.Z && git push --tags

Note: We don't use GitHub "releases" since there's no release artifact other than the already published rendering.