[Feature request] xbps-install interactive choice for selecting virtual provider
JamiKettunen opened this issue · comments
Some packages depend on virtual?java-runtime for example which is provided by openjdk17-jre and openjdk11-jre at least. Currently (xbps-0.59.1_7) though the default provider to install appears to be completely arbitrary and depends on the sorting of the package index on the mirror.
Obviously if the user has configured virtualpkg=... in /etc/xbps.d or whatever that should be prioritized (or given as the default choice when just pressing enter?) when installing something and installed always during non-interactive cases with --yes (just like it works presently).
Related code:
- https://github.com/void-linux/xbps/blob/0.59.1/include/xbps.h.in#L1698-L1708
- https://github.com/void-linux/xbps/blob/0.59.1/lib/repo.c#L389-L421
Here's how an "interactive virtual provider choice" looks like on pacman (Arch Linux) for example:
# pacman -S java-runtime
:: There are 4 providers available for java-runtime:
:: Repository extra
1) jre-openjdk 2) jre11-openjdk 3) jre17-openjdk 4) jre8-openjdk
Enter a number (default=1):
@classabbyamp @paper42 would know a bit more about this as we discussed this a few months back in August on #xbps.
If you want to select another provider during install-time without setting a preference via xbps.d(5) you have to name the provider package also in the same install command or later remove the one you didn't want after replacing it.