The intent here is to benchmark different PHP routing solutions. This is a micro-optimization, done purely out of dumb curiosity.
- the test script is forked form https://github.com/tyler-sommer/php-router-benchmark
- test frmaework is: https://github.com/ulue/nice-bench. it is forked form
nice/bench - Test time 2017.12.03
Please see ./records
always use
dev-masterbranch
nikic/fast-routehttps://github.com/nikic/FastRouteinhere/sroutehttps://github.com/inhere/php-srouterklein/kleinhttps://github.com/klein/klein.phpaltorouter/altorouterhttps://github.com/dannyvankooten/AltoRouternoahbuscher/macawhttps://github.com/noahbuscher/Macawnoodlehaus/dispatchhttps://github.com/noodlehaus/dispatchleague/routehttps://github.com/thephpleague/routedannyvankooten/php-routerhttps://github.com/dannyvankooten/PHP-Routerphroute/phroutehttps://github.com/mrjgreen/phroutesymfony/routinghttps://github.com/symfony/routingcorneltek/puxhttps://github.com/c9s/Puxbramus/routerhttps://github.com/bramus/routertorophp/torophphttps://github.com/bramus/routerconformity/routerhttps://github.com/leemason/routerbephp/routerhttps://github.com/bephp/routerbaryshev/tree-routehttps://github.com/baryshev/TreeRoutemindplay/timberhttps://github.com/mindplay-dk/timber
Clone the repo, run composer install, run php run-tests.php.
You can install the Pux extension to test that as well. If the extension is not installed, the tests will fallback to the pure PHP implementation of Pux.
To test the R3 library, you also need to install that extension. If the extension is not installed, the tests for R3 will be skipped.
The current test creates 1000 routes, each with a randomized prefix and postfix, with 9 parameters each.
It was run with the Pux and R3 extensions enabled.
An example route: /9b37eef21e/{arg1}/{arg2}/{arg3}/{arg4}/{arg5}/{arg6}/{arg7}/{arg8}/{arg9}/bda37e9f9b
collect code write in the first-test-cases.php
- nikic/fast-route: 69.603 ms
- nikic/fast-route(cached): 3.734 ms
- inhere/sroute(SRouter): 29.704 ms
- inhere/sroute(ORouter): 29.164 ms
- Symfony/routing: 16.976 ms
- Symfony/routing(cached): 17.666 ms
- corneltek/pux(php): 92.823 ms
- altorouter/altorouter: 5.203 ms
- phroute/phroute: 91.662 ms
- noahbuscher/macaw: 8.854 ms
- noodlehaus/dispatch: 7.203 ms
php run-worst-tests.phpThis benchmark matches the last route and unknown route. It generates a randomly prefixed and suffixed route in an attempt to thwart any optimization. 1,000 routes each with 9 arguments.
This benchmark consists of 22 tests. Each test is executed 1,000 times, the results pruned, and then averaged. Values that fall outside of 3 standard d eviations of the mean are discarded.
| Test Name | Results | Time(ms) | + Interval | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| inhere/sroute(ORouter) - unknown route (1000 routes) | 987 | 0.010222 | +0.000000 | baseline |
| inhere/sroute(SRouter) - unknown route (1000 routes) | 984 | 0.012239 | +0.002017 | 20% slower |
| inhere/sroute(SRouter) - last route (1000 routes) | 999 | 0.024386 | +0.014820 | 155% slower |
| inhere/sroute(ORouter) - last route (1000 routes) | 975 | 0.024554 | +0.014989 | 157% slower |
| Symfony Cached - last route (1000 routes) | 997 | 0.029091 | +0.019525 | 204% slower |
| Symfony Cached - unknown route (1000 routes) | 985 | 0.037226 | +0.027661 | 289% slower |
| FastRoute - unknown route (1000 routes) | 988 | 0.089904 | +0.080338 | 840% slower |
| FastRoute(cached) - unknown route (1000 routes) | 988 | 0.091358 | +0.081792 | 855% slower |
| FastRoute(cached) - last route (1000 routes) | 999 | 0.092567 | +0.083001 | 868% slower |
| FastRoute - last route (1000 routes) | 999 | 0.113668 | +0.104103 | 1088% slower |
| phroute/phroute - unknown route (1000 routes) | 987 | 0.168871 | +0.159305 | 1665% slower |
| phroute/phroute - last route (1000 routes) | 999 | 0.169914 | +0.160348 | 1676% slower |
| Pux PHP - unknown route (1000 routes) | 981 | 0.866280 | +0.856714 | 8956% slower |
| Pux PHP - last route (1000 routes) | 999 | 0.941322 | +0.931757 | 9741% slower |
| AltoRouter - unknown route (1000 routes) | 982 | 2.245384 | +2.235819 | 23373% slower |
| AltoRouter - last route (1000 routes) | 979 | 2.281995 | +2.272429 | 23756% slower |
| Symfony - unknown route (1000 routes) | 984 | 2.488247 | +2.478681 | 25912% slower |
| Symfony - last route (1000 routes) | 999 | 2.540170 | +2.530605 | 26455% slower |
| Macaw - unknown route (1000 routes) | 982 | 2.617635 | +2.608069 | 27265% slower |
| Macaw - last route (1000 routes) | 999 | 2.700128 | +2.690562 | 28127% slower |
| noodlehaus/dispatch - unknown route (1000 routes) | 972 | 4.729197 | +4.719632 | 49339% slower |
| noodlehaus/dispatch - last route (1000 routes) | 999 | 4.942050 | +4.932484 | 51564% slower |
php run-first-tests.phpThis benchmark tests how quickly each router can match the first route. 1,000 routes each with 9 arguments.
This benchmark consists of 11 tests. Each test is executed 1,000 times, the results pruned, and then averaged. Values that fall outside of 3 standard deviations of the mean are discarded.
| Test Name | Results | Time(ms) | + Interval | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pux PHP - first route(1000) | 997 | 0.006587 | +0.000000 | baseline |
| FastRoute - first route(1000) | 999 | 0.008751 | +0.002165 | 33% slower |
| phroute/phroute - first route (1000 routes) | 999 | 0.021902 | +0.015315 | 233% slower |
| Symfony Dumped - first route | 997 | 0.022254 | +0.015667 | 238% slower |
| ORouter - first route(1000) | 993 | 0.025026 | +0.018440 | 280% slower |
| SRouter - first route(1000) | 997 | 0.025553 | +0.018967 | 288% slower |
| noodlehaus/dispatch - first route (1000 routes) | 989 | 0.030126 | +0.023540 | 357% slower |
| AltoRouter - first route (1000 routes) | 994 | 0.041488 | +0.034902 | 530% slower |
| Symfony - first route | 991 | 0.047335 | +0.040748 | 619% slower |
| FastRoute(cached) - first route(1000) | 999 | 0.092703 | +0.086117 | 1307% slower |
| Macaw - first route (1000 routes) | 999 | 2.710132 | +2.703545 | 41047% slower |