Sample "07-usbstorage" fails with Pi5
pottendo opened this issue · comments
Hi,
trying to run 07-usbstorage I get
logger: Circle 45.3.1 started on Raspberry Pi 5 (AArch64)
00:00:00.13 timer: SpeedFactor is 7.69
00:00:00.23 xhci: HW reset failed
00:00:00.23 usb: Cannot initialize xHCI device #0
on a RPi 5 / 4GB setup.
Happens with or without usbpowerdelay=1000 in config.txt
Config:
$ cat ../../Config.mk
PREFIX64 = aarch64-none-elf-
AARCH = 64
RASPPI = 5
DEFINE += -DARM_ALLOW_MULTI_CORE
DEFINE += -DSERIAL_DEVICE_DEFAULT=0
bye, pottendo
PS: here config.txt:
#
# Enable 64-bit mode (AArch64)
#
# This file must be copied along with the generated kernel image
# onto a SDHC card with FAT file system, if 64-bit mode is used.
#
# This file also enables the possibility to use two displays with
# the Raspberry Pi 4 and selects the required mode for the USB host
# controller of the Compute Module 4.
#
arm_64bit=1
#dtoverlay=uart0
#dtparam=uart0_console
[pi02]
kernel=kernel8.img
[pi2]
kernel=kernel8.img
[pi3]
kernel=kernel8.img
[pi3+]
kernel=kernel8.img
[pi4]
armstub=armstub8-rpi4.bin
kernel=kernel8-rpi4.img
max_framebuffers=2
[cm4]
otg_mode=1
[pi5]
#dtoverlay=vc4-kms-v3d
#max_framebuffers=2
gpu_mem=16
kernel_address=0x80000
kernel=kernel_2712.img
usbpowerdelay=1000
Hi, I retrieved the booloader_version:
$ vcgencmd bootloader_version
2024/01/24 12:16:01
version 1aeae380dd5256134eea87a7e0367a9939f806b0 (release)
timestamp 1706098561
update-time 1706967189
capabilities 0x0000007f
$ sudo raspi-config
BOOTLOADER: up to date
CURRENT: Wed 24 Jan 12:16:01 UTC 2024 (1706098561)
LATEST: Wed 24 Jan 12:16:01 UTC 2024 (1706098561)
RELEASE: latest (/lib/firmware/raspberrypi/bootloader-2712/latest)
Use raspi-config to change the release.
thx, pottendo
Thank you. I've found a problem in the HWReset() function of the xHCI driver. It failed, when the controller was already running. I fixed it on the rpi5 branch. Can you please try again?
Here the slightly different output:
logger: Circle 45.3.1 started on Raspberry Pi 5 (AArch64)
00:00:00.13 timer: SpeedFactor is 7.69
00:00:00.78 xhcidev: Cannot set device address (4)
00:00:00.78 kernel: Compile time: Feb 4 2024 20:00:32
00:00:00.79 kernel: USB mass storage device not found
I tried an older USB key in both USB3 (the blue ones) and USB - same result.
This USB key works in other Pi models using Circle.
bye, pottendo
PS: also tried sdcard boot, same result.
There is another update on the rpi5 branch. With this all my USB flash drives do work at the RPi 5. Can you please try your USB device again?
hi,
with the same USB key as initially tried it still delivers
logger: Circle 45.3.1 started on Raspberry Pi 5 (AArch64)
00:00:00.13 timer: SpeedFactor is 7.69
00:00:00.58 xhcidev: Cannot set device address (4)
00:00:00.88 kernel: Compile time: Feb 5 2024 18:13:48
00:00:00.88 kernel: USB mass storage device not found
but with another one (USB3 adapter for a microSD card) it works:
logger: Circle 45.3.1 started on Raspberry Pi 5 (AArch64)
00:00:00.13 timer: SpeedFactor is 7.69
00:00:00.88 usbdev3: Device ven5e3-749 found (SS)
00:00:00.89 usbdev3: Product: Generic USB3.0 Card Reader
00:00:00.94 usbdev3: Interface int8-6-50 found
00:00:00.94 usbdev3: Using device/interface int8-6-50
00:00:01.37 umsd: Capacity is 59320 MByte
00:00:01.37 xhciroot: Port 3: Device configured
00:00:01.37 kernel: Compile time: Feb 5 2024 18:13:48
00:00:01.38 kernel: Dumping the partition table
00:00:01.38 kernel: # Status Type 1stSector Sectors
00:00:01.39 kernel: 1 00 0C 8192 1048576
00:00:01.39 kernel: 2 00 83 1056768 120430592
00:00:01.40 kernel: 3 00 00 0 0
00:00:01.40 kernel: 4 00 00 0 0
maybe this has worked always - don't know.
Still the problem remains with this very old USB key - not so important, but definitely a regression as this USB key works with Circle with my models Pi3 and Pi4.
You may close this issue anyway - as you can't reproduce it.
I can try to instrument circle to get more information out - let me know if this is something you want to do...
thx, pottendo