rebipp / ppi

REBIPP: Plant-Pollinator Interactions Data Vocabulary

Home Page:https://ppi.rebipp.org.br

Geek Repo:Geek Repo

Github PK Tool:Github PK Tool

plantPlaceOfContact

zedomel opened this issue · comments

Field Value
GUID
Rebipp Class rebipp:Interaction
Label plantPlaceOfContact
Definition A list (concatenated and separated) of places (i.e. structures) in the plant that contacts its interacting partner during an Interaction.
Comments Recommended best practice is to separate the values in a list with space vertical bar space ( `
Examples
Controlled vocabulary
Darwin Core Class Event
Cardinality One to one
Reference Protocol

I am not sure what this term is referred to...

I was also in doubt, as well as @fonturbel...

Does this term refer to the parts of the flower that are touched by the floral visitor at the time of the visit to collect some resource? If so, better switch to flowerPlaceOfContact. And the answer options would be the main parts of the flower: anthers, stigma, petals....

@carmensspires and @fonturbel I believe that the concept here is to capture all the possible plant structures/organs that an animal touches during visitation. It can be very specific as floral parts (anther, stigma, petals) or more general as whole plant structures (flower, leaf).

Maybe we should change the definition to:

A list (concatenated and separated) of structures or organs of the plant touched by an animal
Then, we can adjust the Comments to explain that it can be filled with specific floral parts or more general plant structures. As well as, we should provide examples with both scenarios.

A controlled vocabulary of plant structures/organs should also be provided here!

Putting the definition this way, I'm wondering now if we still need the term pollinate (or touchesReproductiveStructures) #22. Since this term is filled with reproductive structures of the plant is possible to infer that the animal touches the reproductive structures of the flower, and so, "pollinates" it (as defined in #22).

If the interaction is between plant and pollinator, this term should be related only to the reproductive organs. If the interaction is pollination, the other parts of the plant do not matter. @carmensspires I agree with flowerPlaceOfContact.

Change term's label to flowerPlaceOfContact. But the conflicts with #22 is not resolved.