Support for Manual FX
jmgomezpoveda opened this issue · comments
I have disabled auto-fx and sold some USD shares. Now in the report they appear as 100% loss.
It seems to be failing to link the multi-line sale operation (in USD) with the single USD-EUR exchange. Sales with auto-fx enabled used to work fine.
In the CSV file, with autofx enabled I can see multiple pairs of lines (one per Buy or Sell line):
02-04-2024,15:40,02-04-2024,UNITED CONTINENTAL HOLDINGS,US9100471096,FX Credit,1.0737,USD,3456.78,USD,0.00,aaaaaaaa-bbbb-cccc-dddd-eeeeeeeeeeee
02-04-2024,15:40,02-04-2024,UNITED CONTINENTAL HOLDINGS,US9100471096,FX Debit,,EUR,-2345.67,EUR,95.80,aaaaaaaa-bbbb-cccc-dddd-eeeeeeeeeeee
However, what I see with auto-fx disabled is one single pair of lines:
18-04-2024,06:57,17-04-2024,,,FX Credit,,EUR,123456.78,EUR,123556.78,
18-04-2024,06:57,17-04-2024,,,FX Debit,1.0699,USD,-234567.89,USD,0.00,
Note that since manual fx operations are not linked to any specific Buy or Sell operation, the last field which used to link the sale and the fx operations is missing, as well as the 4th and 5th fields that indicate the stock which this currency exchange is related to.
the last field which used to link the sale and the fx operations is missing, as well as the 4th and 5th fields that indicate the stock which this currency exchange is related to.
sounds like it's going to be hard to support this if we can't rely on that GUID to be present.
Thanks for reporting this anyway. I'll look into it (if I can find other CSV samples, and time). PRs are welcome too.
edit:
I had a look, and I don't think we can track this at all, since the FX transactions are not correlated in any way to the actual buy and sell transactions. I will mark this as "won't fix" and add it to the list of limitations of degiro-bookkeeper. Thanks again