ployground / bsdploy

BSDploy is a tool to provision, configure and maintain FreeBSD jails.

Geek Repo:Geek Repo

Github PK Tool:Github PK Tool

ezjail and /etc/jail.conf

abelbabel opened this issue · comments

As ezjail still does not support new /etc/jail.conf style and the day comes closer where FreeBSD will drop support for legacy rc-jail-conf what is the solution for the not so far future?

Getting @tomster to poke erdgeist as often as necessary to get him to support the new style 😃

Another way would be creating a substitute for ploy_ezjail which works directly with FreeBSD. I understand what ezjail does quite a bit better now and this might be the way forward. Haven't decided yet.

Speaking of substitutes iocage might be an interresting candidate, too.

agreed, iocage is an interesting candidate. but currently we're still pretty much invested in ezjail. i'm actually nudging its author (we share an office) to release 3.4.2 with some fixes.

eventually, ezjail will adjust to the new jail.conf style but it's a tricky issue in itself - basically the whole jail config situation is more or less in limbo on FreeBSD-CURRENT now, from what i've learnt.

bsdploy's stance is to let others deal with this until our hand is forced :-)

+1 for iocage! It would be nice to be agnostic towards the jail-management utility, yes?

I would suggest glancing qjail once, its basically ezjail plus some enhancements. I am liking it.

@mzs114 i'm familiar with the history of qjail and i can assure you that (unlike iocage) it is probably the last piece of software that i would consider integrating into bsdploy.

@tomster is there such a reason to not use qjail? :-?

I did not use iocage as it requires ZFS and some of my nodes have UFS. The other one I used was CBSD for multinode management of jails https://www.bsdstore.ru/en/about.html
In fact, I was wondering whether we can make bsdploy work with CBSD.

I'm actually thinking about not using any wrapper at all and just do a ploy_jail.

@mzs114 i won't go into any details here re: qjail, but if you're really interested check the archives of the FreeBSD jail mailing list. it's not pretty, though :(