Rail GTFS feeds are invalid

[Marcus]

Hi,

There seems to be a problem with the GTFS feeds for Rail. They fail validation due to duplicate route_id and trip_id affecting feeds from various dates.

For example, this extract from the latest feed trips.txt. In this small section alone there are multiple duplicates of trip_id (409078, 409089 and 409100) which in the specification must be unique:

route_id,service_id,trip_id,trip_headsign,trip_short_name,direction_id,wheelchair_accessible,bikes_allowed
408729,42,409078,Z01507,,0,0,0
408729,42,409078,Z01507,,0,0,0
408729,42,409078,Z01507,,0,0,0
408729,17,409073,Z01507,,0,0,0
408729,41,409074,Z01507,,0,0,0
408729,24,409075,Z01507,,0,0,0
408729,18,409076,Z01507,,0,0,0
408729,44,409077,Z01507,,0,0,0
408729,42,409078,Z01507,,0,0,0
408729,25,409080,Z01507,,0,0,0
408729,42,409089,Z01509,,0,0,0
408729,42,409089,Z01509,,0,0,0
408729,42,409089,Z01509,,0,0,0
408729,17,409084,Z01509,,0,0,0
408729,41,409085,Z01509,,0,0,0
408729,24,409086,Z01509,,0,0,0
408729,18,409087,Z01509,,0,0,0
408729,45,409088,Z01509,,0,0,0
408729,42,409089,Z01509,,0,0,0
408729,20,409090,Z01509,,0,0,0
408729,25,409091,Z01509,,0,0,0
408729,42,409100,Z01511,,0,0,0
408729,42,409100,Z01511,,0,0,0
408729,42,409100,Z01511,,0,0,0

Another example, this from the 23 October 2018 feed, routes.txt. Repeated route_id 406476. route_id must be unique in the spec:

route_id,agency_id,route_short_name,route_long_name,route_type,route_text_color,route_color,route_url,route_desc
405755,,Z:NBG->NBG,Z train service from NBG to NBG,2,,,,Train. Standard class only. Reservation not possible
405808,,Z:ENN->ENN,Z train service from ENN to ENN,2,,,,Train. Standard class only. Reservation not possible
405872,,Z:STQ->STQ,Z boat service from STQ to STQ,4,,,,Boat. Standard class only. Reservation not possible
406476,,Z:STQ->SOU,Z bus service from STQ to SOU,3,,,,Bus. Standard class only. Reservation not possible
406476,,Z:SOU->SOU,Z bus service from SOU to SOU,3,,,,Bus. Standard class only. Reservation not possible
406479,,Z:XRD->XRD,Z boat service from XRD to XRD,4,,,,Boat. Standard class only. Reservation not possible
406617,,Z:PMH->PMS,Z bus service from PMH to PMS,3,,,,Bus. Standard class only. Reservation not possible
406672,,Z:PMH->PMH,Z boat service from PMH to PMH,4,,,,Boat. Standard class only. Reservation not possible

[Linus Norton]

@marcusyoung sorry I missed this issue. Is it still a problem? Do you have a tool I use to validate the feed?