⚡️ Gas Reports Summary for `CreateX`
pcaversaccio opened this issue · comments
Context
Gas reports for CreateX:
forge test --gas-reportI get the impression that the
forgegas reports are not so reliable in profiling the gas costs forCreateX(some numbers are just blatantly wrong).
Summary Runtime Costs
My personal opinion is that we should not use a via_ir = true configuration due to the following reasons:
- Deployment costs should not matter (
via_irwins here), - The new pipeline doesn't offer any huge gas savings (I always use the default optimiser steps
dhfoDgvulfnTUtnIf), - Block explorer verification will be easier by not using
via_irsince otherwise you must upload a standard JSON input file as Etherscan and Blockscout don't allow in the UI to configure the optimiser settings.
➛ My personal opinion is to choose optimizer_runs = 6_942_000 since optimizer_runs = 10_000_000 doesn't offer any additional significant gas savings & because of the meme factor 😄.
Option 1
Configuration:
optimizer = trueoptimizer_runs = 6_942_000via_ir = false
| src/CreateX.sol:CreateX contract | | | | | |
|---------------------------------------------------------------------|-----------------|---------------------|---------------------|---------------------|---------|
| Deployment Cost | Deployment Size | | | | |
| 2370524 | 12054 | | | | |
| Function Name | min | avg | median | max | # calls |
| computeCreate2Address(bytes32,bytes32) | 559 | 559 | 559 | 559 | 1 |
| computeCreate2Address(bytes32,bytes32,address) | 580 | 580 | 580 | 580 | 37 |
| computeCreate3Address(bytes32) | 551 | 551 | 551 | 551 | 1 |
| computeCreate3Address(bytes32,address) | 648 | 648 | 648 | 648 | 13 |
| computeCreateAddress(address,uint256) | 582 | 907 | 918 | 1011 | 9 |
| computeCreateAddress(uint256) | 539 | 739 | 739 | 940 | 2 |
| deployCreate | 32866 | 4468696730258534196 | 4468696730258690252 | 8937393460516723417 | 4 |
| deployCreate2(bytes) | 34455 | 1787478692103751147 | 672889 | 8937393460516702614 | 5 |
| deployCreate2(bytes32,bytes) | 34228 | 2234348365129359616 | 353432 | 8937393460516697372 | 4 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 35063 | 893739346052220707 | 683843 | 8937393460516689843 | 10 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 35154 | 893739346052222859 | 683936 | 8937393460516689730 | 10 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 1883 | 1117174182564938042 | 681904 | 8937393460516721268 | 8 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 2787 | 1489565576753136221 | 685888 | 8937393460516690343 | 6 |
| deployCreate2Clone(address,bytes) | 48537 | 1787478692103388783 | 74846 | 8937393460516690542 | 5 |
| deployCreate2Clone(bytes32,address,bytes) | 48413 | 1787478692103389766 | 77011 | 8937393460516692031 | 5 |
| deployCreate3(bytes) | 77062 | 3790412405130131143 | 724440 | 8937393460516392418 | 7 |
| deployCreate3(bytes32,bytes) | 1254 | 4433785037053310919 | 4398873343848424821 | 8937393460516392781 | 4 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 45706 | 1477928345684875189 | 735349 | 8937393460516361104 | 12 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 45664 | 1477928345684879200 | 735462 | 8937393460516361934 | 12 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 2712 | 2533591449744862282 | 732319 | 8937393460516362238 | 7 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 2787 | 2412080621446464731 | 732329 | 8937393460516362773 | 11 |
| deployCreateAndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 33399 | 1117174182564945483 | 679699 | 8937393460516702624 | 8 |
| deployCreateAndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 33602 | 1489565576753248846 | 684813 | 8937393460516702481 | 6 |
| deployCreateClone | 53260 | 2979131153505611705 | 75423 | 8937393460516706433 | 3 |Option 2
Configuration:
optimizer = trueoptimizer_runs = 10_000_000via_ir = false
| src/CreateX.sol:CreateX contract | | | | | |
|---------------------------------------------------------------------|-----------------|---------------------|---------------------|---------------------|---------|
| Deployment Cost | Deployment Size | | | | |
| 2370524 | 12054 | | | | |
| Function Name | min | avg | median | max | # calls |
| computeCreate2Address(bytes32,bytes32) | 559 | 559 | 559 | 559 | 1 |
| computeCreate2Address(bytes32,bytes32,address) | 580 | 580 | 580 | 580 | 43 |
| computeCreate3Address(bytes32) | 551 | 551 | 551 | 551 | 1 |
| computeCreate3Address(bytes32,address) | 648 | 648 | 648 | 648 | 17 |
| computeCreateAddress(address,uint256) | 582 | 908 | 964 | 1011 | 9 |
| computeCreateAddress(uint256) | 539 | 763 | 763 | 987 | 2 |
| deployCreate | 32866 | 4468696730258534060 | 4468696730258690281 | 8937393460516722812 | 4 |
| deployCreate2(bytes) | 34455 | 1787478692103749828 | 672889 | 8937393460516696018 | 5 |
| deployCreate2(bytes32,bytes) | 2101 | 3574957384206698057 | 34248 | 8937393460516722935 | 5 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 35063 | 893739346052218787 | 683843 | 8937393460516690742 | 10 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 35154 | 893739346052223528 | 683936 | 8937393460516689718 | 10 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 34138 | 1276770494359928442 | 683559 | 8937393460516691677 | 7 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 1961 | 1489565576753130647 | 685878 | 8937393460516689238 | 6 |
| deployCreate2Clone(address,bytes) | 55145 | 2234348365129223652 | 74846 | 8937393460516689771 | 4 |
| deployCreate2Clone(bytes32,address,bytes) | 1367 | 1489565576752828240 | 75322 | 8937393460516692169 | 6 |
| deployCreate3(bytes) | 77062 | 3790412405130131095 | 724440 | 8937393460516392256 | 7 |
| deployCreate3(bytes32,bytes) | 76801 | 4422147805985031721 | 4398873343848423992 | 8937393460516392754 | 6 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 45553 | 1477928345684875038 | 735349 | 8937393460516361197 | 12 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 77746 | 1612285468019864591 | 735462 | 8937393460516361028 | 11 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 2699 | 1773514014821628288 | 734785 | 8937393460516364250 | 10 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 1961 | 993043717835569402 | 734413 | 8937393460516361887 | 9 |
| deployCreateAndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 33399 | 2234348365129531318 | 684741 | 8937393460516721014 | 8 |
| deployCreateAndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 33602 | 1489565576753250245 | 684813 | 8937393460516704174 | 6 |
| deployCreateClone | 46560 | 1489565576752829119 | 49949 | 8937393460516706274 | 6 |Option 3
Configuration:
optimizer = trueoptimizer_runs = 6_942_000via_ir = true
☠️💀
| src/CreateX.sol:CreateX contract | | | | | |
|---------------------------------------------------------------------|-----------------|---------------------|---------------------|---------------------|---------|
| Deployment Cost | Deployment Size | | | | |
| 1860013 | 9428 | | | | |
| Function Name | min | avg | median | max | # calls |
| computeCreate2Address(bytes32,bytes32) | 623 | 623 | 623 | 623 | 1 |
| computeCreate2Address(bytes32,bytes32,address) | 770 | 770 | 770 | 770 | 42 |
| computeCreate3Address(bytes32) | 571 | 571 | 571 | 571 | 1 |
| computeCreate3Address(bytes32,address) | 607 | 607 | 607 | 607 | 15 |
| computeCreateAddress(address,uint256) | 500 | 833 | 840 | 956 | 9 |
| computeCreateAddress(uint256) | 350 | 520 | 520 | 690 | 2 |
| deployCreate | 32838 | 2234348365129382625 | 393851 | 8937393460516709962 | 4 |
| deployCreate2(bytes) | 34256 | 1787478692103800627 | 757523 | 8937393460516696311 | 5 |
| deployCreate2(bytes32,bytes) | 33336 | 4468696730258552594 | 4468696730258727279 | 8937393460516722482 | 4 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 35056 | 744782788376911022 | 767015 | 8937393460516689916 | 12 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 35178 | 812490314592995098 | 768254 | 8937393460516690131 | 11 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 2239 | 1117174182564976152 | 767692 | 8937393460516690333 | 8 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 35033 | 1489565576753306014 | 771309 | 8937393460516690212 | 6 |
| deployCreate2Clone(address,bytes) | 54904 | 2234348365129223361 | 74491 | 8937393460516689558 | 4 |
| deployCreate2Clone(bytes32,address,bytes) | 53945 | 2234348365129224383 | 76584 | 8937393460516690422 | 4 |
| deployCreate3(bytes) | 76910 | 3790412405130160460 | 799837 | 8937393460516371615 | 7 |
| deployCreate3(bytes32,bytes) | 77005 | 4422147805985053801 | 4398873343848462424 | 8937393460516372836 | 6 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 77401 | 1612285468019912131 | 810018 | 8937393460516341162 | 11 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 45644 | 1477928345684928134 | 810408 | 8937393460516341280 | 12 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 1780 | 2216892518526867853 | 808577 | 8937393460516342214 | 8 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 2239 | 1612285468019698086 | 809416 | 8937393460516341585 | 11 |
| deployCreateAndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 33532 | 1489565576753305759 | 768900 | 8937393460516702944 | 6 |
| deployCreateAndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 33611 | 1117174182564986586 | 760989 | 8937393460516703673 | 8 |
| deployCreateClone | 53326 | 2979131153505611625 | 75391 | 8937393460516706158 | 3 |Option 4
Configuration:
optimizer = trueoptimizer_runs = 10_000_000via_ir = true
☠️💀
| src/CreateX.sol:CreateX contract | | | | | |
|---------------------------------------------------------------------|-----------------|---------------------|---------------------|---------------------|---------|
| Deployment Cost | Deployment Size | | | | |
| 1860013 | 9428 | | | | |
| Function Name | min | avg | median | max | # calls |
| computeCreate2Address(bytes32,bytes32) | 623 | 623 | 623 | 623 | 1 |
| computeCreate2Address(bytes32,bytes32,address) | 770 | 770 | 770 | 770 | 41 |
| computeCreate3Address(bytes32) | 571 | 571 | 571 | 571 | 1 |
| computeCreate3Address(bytes32,address) | 607 | 607 | 607 | 607 | 15 |
| computeCreateAddress(address,uint256) | 500 | 816 | 840 | 955 | 9 |
| computeCreateAddress(uint256) | 350 | 520 | 520 | 690 | 2 |
| deployCreate | 32838 | 2979131153505832505 | 754858 | 8937393460516709820 | 3 |
| deployCreate2(bytes) | 34256 | 1787478692103800716 | 757523 | 8937393460516696759 | 5 |
| deployCreate2(bytes32,bytes) | 2129 | 4468696730258363881 | 4468696730258365250 | 8937393460516722895 | 4 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 35087 | 812490314592992551 | 768150 | 8937393460516690644 | 11 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 35276 | 893739346052291025 | 768254 | 8937393460516689488 | 10 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 3118 | 1986087435670725602 | 767440 | 8937393460516720825 | 9 |
| deployCreate2AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 3062 | 993043717835623063 | 767371 | 8937393460516691473 | 9 |
| deployCreate2Clone(address,bytes) | 48211 | 1489565576752831652 | 64697 | 8937393460516689582 | 6 |
| deployCreate2Clone(bytes32,address,bytes) | 47882 | 1787478692103389438 | 76506 | 8937393460516691581 | 5 |
| deployCreate3(bytes) | 76910 | 4416329190450909174 | 4398873343848462089 | 8937393460516370947 | 8 |
| deployCreate3(bytes32,bytes) | 76863 | 4422147805985053576 | 4398873343848462122 | 8937393460516371785 | 6 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 70701 | 1612285468019911552 | 810018 | 8937393460516341258 | 11 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 77791 | 1612285468019917388 | 810408 | 8937393460516340412 | 11 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 1780 | 812490314592701599 | 45081 | 8937393460516341757 | 11 |
| deployCreate3AndInit(bytes32,bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 3131 | 2216892518526881854 | 812739 | 8937393460516342081 | 8 |
| deployCreateAndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256)) | 33532 | 1489565576753304705 | 768900 | 8937393460516703320 | 6 |
| deployCreateAndInit(bytes,bytes,(uint256,uint256),address) | 33599 | 1276770494359981812 | 765475 | 8937393460516704003 | 7 |
| deployCreateClone | 53326 | 2979131153505611556 | 75391 | 8937393460516705953 | 3 |Final decision:
optimizer = trueoptimizer_runs = 10_000_000via_ir = false