Ability to Edit Viewable POI Categories
Swamp2k9 opened this issue · comments
Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.
It's a bit tedious when searching for categories that aren't in Organic Map's default list.
Describe the ideal solution
I'd like only have categories that I'm interested in (amusement arcade, pub, etc.) within the categories. The Categories list could be editable in a Settings menu.
Describe alternatives you have considered
As a workaround, I would have to type out the category in search and filter through the outputted list.
Did you know that you can search for any category/object type without using categories listed in Organic Maps? Just type anything in the search field.
Hi!
Yes, I'm aware of this feature. I've been doing that as a workaround. 🙂
The feature's use-case would be for users that have interests in particular POIs rather then the recommended default ones (bank, entertainment, water, etc). Providing an editable list would provide a bit of personalization for users.
Also there is a "history" tab where one can see and re-use one's recent searches. So it kinda becomes close to a user-specific list of the most common searches..
Also amusement arcades are included into the "Entertainment" default category, while pubs and bars are in the "Nighlife" category.
Maybe adding "favorite" searches could be a much easier option (compared to editable categories list).
I like the idea of adding favorites.
Also amusement arcades are included into the "Entertainment" default category, while pubs and bars are in the "Nighlife" category.
I was thinking more along the lines of having the 'Categories' page be customizable. It can stay as-is for defaults, but users should have the option to dismantle and show particular POIs. They could then decide which ones they'd like displayed on the map.
Example: Options -> Categories -> (List all POI Categories with sub-categories)
Entertainment
- Bowling Alley
- Amusement Arcade
- Pool Hall
Another use case would allow users to view multiple POIs of a particular category at once without the unwanted sub-categories.
Example: If a user wants to view only Bowling Alleys and Amusement Arcades (nothing else in Entertainment).
Additionally, users could choose to view multiple different sub-categories at the same time, such as pubs, pool halls, and ATMs.
I think its related also to
Adding a favorite category can be implemented by showing a star on the right from the displayed suggestion in blue during the search.
But essentially it should be the same as a properly working recent history. Search categories (popular ones!) should be there at the top.
I see what you mean.
Did you know that you can search for any category/object type without using categories listed in Organic Maps? Just type anything in the search field.
I've tried is again and compared it to the search functionality of OsmAnd. Video here.
When searching through OsmAnd, it searches only the POI category (amusement arcade) as well as displaying them by distance.
In OM, it seems to sort by name. For some reason, it's not filtering by 'amusement_arcade' POI category. Instead, it's adding shopping arcades, tunnels, and theme parks.
////
I've also checked out OsmAnd's category filtering function. Video here. Its functionality is what I'm looking for. If OM could implement this, it would be the perfect app!
If avoiding complexity to accommodate the average user is an issue, I'd suggest locking this feature in a "Pro" option in the settings menu.