mt-mods / plantlife_modpack

Geek Repo:Geek Repo

Github PK Tool:Github PK Tool

Possibly textures in vines sub mod have ambiguous original license

sirrobzeroone opened this issue · comments

Not a major issue, but I thought it was worth noting the Vines textures were originally listed as under CC. Which is not an actual license but rather the category of licences - I notice the plantlife_modpack has everything flagged as by CC BY-SA 4.0, so possibly @VanessaE solved this issue (hopefully Vanessa see's this issue and can comment - fingers crossed) but wanted to note the potential discontinuity in the CC as the textures bundled with vines appear to be the originals.

I did try trawling back through to the original vines mod by Bas080 - https://forum.minetest.net/viewtopic.php?t=2344 but looks like it's always been just listed as CC. I would guess he meant CC0 given the code is WTFPL however can't really draw that conclusion - last logon for Bas080 was in 2017 so I don't like the chances of reaching him.

For my own purposes I'm recreating/drawing the vine textures and will then re-release those as CC0 clearly. I know a pedantic point and probably in real terms a bit of a none issue but I know MT in general tries to keep a clear idea of licensing etc - also aware of CC license trolling some people are doing at the moment.

If I get super motivated and this seems worth cleaning up I'll do the rope as well and add a pull request for plantlife_modpack. If not I'll at least add a comment to this issue noting where the vine textures can be found so they can be pulled across if anyone's concerned- sorry very time poor at the moment :(.

commented

This was fixed months ago.