Giters

life-itself / web3

Making sense of web3 & crypto. Introduction to key concepts and ideas. Rigorous, constructive analysis of key claims pro and con. A look at the deeper hopes and aspirations.

Home Page:https://web3.lifeitself.org/

Geek Repo:Geek Repo

Github PK Tool:Github PK Tool

Web3 and Crypto Claims Database

rufuspollock opened this issue · comments

commented

Create a comprehensive claims database listing the claims we have identified, their link to aspirations and status on evaluation

Job Stories

Focus is on first one atm!

[Editor] When building the guide i want to know what claims there are and whether we have analyzed them to what status so that i can organize the guide and plan final work

[Contributor] When doing analysis I want to know what claims there are (and their importance) so that i can choose which to analyse next

[User] When looking at making sense project I want to know what claims you have listed and evaluated so that I can look at hte one that is interesting to me

Acceptance

  • A list of all claims we have identified ✅2022-09-09 see https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/12Yh1kuxH4uoposLUJsJifM2W_zixkAhlc7QgcKavfls/edit#gid=717497239
    • (Rough) Title
    • Organized by aspiration
  • Notes on which we have analyzed and to what extent
    • Have we looked at it?
    • Does a dedicated page exist for it?
    • Have we found evidence of this claim being made?
    • Have we done a steel man?
    • Do we have a “claim tree”
    • Have we evaluated the claim?
  • What is our evaluation?
  • What is our confidence in evaluation?
  • Links to where we have done this analysis
  • Notes

Bonus

  • Visual representation of claims interconnection

Tasks

Prep

  • Analysis of needs for DB
    • Identify needs for this "database" e.g. a) does it need to be structured b) draft as well as finished material c) planning or publication (or both) ✅2022-09-07 yes is structure, continues all claims both not started, draft, finished on analysis and whether "published" or not (everything may be published but finished state may vary)
  • Choose canonical location ✅2022-09-07 google spreadsheet (though coggle for initial overview)
  • Key features for aspirations database ✅2022-09-07: title, description
  • Key features for claims database: **✅2022-09-07 title, description (short), **

Build it

  • Consolidate list in one place (perhaps structured by aspiration)
    • What material do we already have?
    • Consolidate list of claims into coggle 🚧2022-09-07 done claims section
      • All deep dives are matched in coggle
      • All claims section matched to coggle
      • Refactor claims list in light of this to integrate / de-duplicate
    • Process to spreadsheet
  • Analyze
    • Do we have material on it?
      • Check deep dives
      • Check claims section on wiki
      • Non deep dive episodes
      • Other material
    • Do we have summary
    • Do we have evaluation
    • What is evaluation
commented

Making progress mapping existing materials against claims taxonomy 🎉

image

image