Make it possible to duplicate exercises and/or solutions
choldgraf opened this issue · comments
I believe that @jni mentioned it is common for them to have exercises in individual chapters and additionally at the end of a book. I think that's a pretty common pattern across fields. It would be nice if authors could write one exercise / solution and then be able to display both elsewhere without creating new labels etc.
I wonder if we could just add this as a keyword to the directives, something like:
```{exercise}
:copy: somelabel
```
and it would look for an exercise node of label somelabel and, if so, copy / paste it into the new location (perhaps with a link that points to the original)
This is easily doable - but the user would have to keep track of all the exercise labels and would have to create a new directive for every exercise they want to copy in the new location. Would it make more sense to simply include all?
hmmm - I could see either one being useful, though am not sure what the most-common approach would be. Perhaps @jni has thoughts as I think the elegant SciPy book does this
I'm in the copy-all-directive camp, and agree with @najuzilu that it would be painful to have to keep track of each label. (Totally not my forte in any case. 😂) In Elegant SciPy we copy everything. Specifically:
- the exercises and solutions are both run in their context notebook. The are marked by nested tags essentially as:
<exercise> EX <solution> SOL </solution> </exercise>. - then we grab the stuff between the
<exercise>tags and copy it to the appendix. - then we remove the stuff between the
<solution>tags from the source chapters.
sounds good - then maybe we start with a single "copy all" directive, and if folks ask for single-exercise directives in the future, we can consider adding them then?
I would envision this looking something like
```{copy-exercises}
:include-solutions:
```We can also introduce a copy-solutions directive which will only copy the solutions.
Personally I think it should be only
```{copy-solutions}
:include-exercises:
```
I see clear use case for copying only solutions, or solutions + exercises, but not so much for copying the exercises only. Right?
We don't have a consistent approach yet. I like the system that @jni is suggesting. It would be great to have this available.