Google UMP custom form rejected
javaddeveloper opened this issue · comments
Hello my friend
I have tried to send new update for my app but it rejected for this reason
Guideline 5.1.1 - Legal - Privacy - Data Collection and Storage
We noticed that your app urges or manipulates users to allow the app to track them. Specifically, your app displays its own custom permission request to the user before presenting the iOS permission request.
Next Steps
To resolve this issue, please remove any custom permission requests in your app that appear before the iOS permission request.
could you add an option can disable custom form ?
if you add an option that user can use native iOS ATT alert or use google UMP, it can be great
or i think use google UMP for EU users and use native iOS ATT alert for other users
please add this option faster because last update has a problem for iOS 13 and below
Hey,
Wow. I will have to message google support as I do not believe you can turn this prompt off before the ATT alert. This is all part of the UMP SDK.
Seems like other people have same problem. Cannot find a solution yet. https://support.google.com/admob/thread/88941889?hl=en
Hey,
I have resolved this problem for now
I have added this line before swiftyAds config and this cancel to show google UMP
if #available(iOS 14, *) {
ATTrackingManager.requestTrackingAuthorization(completionHandler: { status in
// Tracking authorization completed. Start loading ads here.
DispatchQueue.main.async {
#if DEBUG
let environment: SwiftyAdsEnvironment = .debug(testDeviceIdentifiers: [], geography: .disabled, resetConsentInfo: true)
#else
let environment: SwiftyAdsEnvironment = .production
#endif
SwiftyAds.shared.setup(
from: tabBarController,
for: environment,
consentStatusDidChange: { status in
print("The consent status has changed: \(status)")
},
completion: { result in
switch result {
case .success(let consentStatus):
print("Setup successful with consent status: \(consentStatus)")
bannerAd = SwiftyAds.shared.makeBannerAd(
in: tabBarController,
adUnitIdType: .plist,
position: .top(isUsingSafeArea: true),
animationDuration: 0.5,
onOpen: ({
print("SwiftyAds banner ad did open")
}),
onClose: ({
print("SwiftyAds banner ad did close")
}),
onError: ({ error in
print("SwiftyAds banner ad error \(error)")
})
)
case .failure(let error):
print("Setup error: \(error)")
}
})
}})
it can resolve my problem now
but if you add this option that user can turn off or turn on google UMP it is more effitiont
Hey,
Just FYI if you go to google funding choices you can delete or unpublish the message for the ATT alert and it will not display.
Still need to see if google will fix it, very annoying.
When using @javaddeveloper example, with notEEA. How does the SwiftyAds handle the ATT? Is the consentStatus .success?
When you run first line
ATTrackingManager.requestTrackingAuthorization(completionHandler: { status in
swiftyAds handle after that and the result could use for swiftyAds
Yes .apple said you should use native iOS alerts without any custom alert
Thanks @javaddeveloper. One more question have you had issues as in #51 ?
Hey,
Google actually recommends that you to display a custom alert before the ATT alert in their documentation, which is just ridiculous. https://developers.google.com/admob/ios/ios14
I am still waiting for proper feedback regards using ATT alert with the UMP SDK. I will keep you posted.
For now your solution is the best option and I have updated the readme to mention this problem.
@crashoverride777 @javaddeveloper I have found following information regarding UMP explainer reject.
Hey,
Thanks for that, that's some good news. Will read the article throughly later and update the documentation.
Hi everyone,
I am courious something. Some apps show specific form for ATT. How can they pass this issue and how can we do it?
@mehyaz please read the thread. I think Apple is a bit picky with how the buttons are labeled and what text is displayed. Please check BanhmiDev/admob_consent#6 (comment).