Darker shades / lightness consistency
toastal opened this issue · comments
Looking at the Colors section, these there is a scale from 0 to 12. The 0 (& often the 1 as well) is perceptually pretty “close” to white, but, with the exception of ‘gray’, ‘stone’ & ‘sand’, the 12 value is nowhere near as close to black (to test, :root { --surface: #000 } to simulate an “OLED Black” theme). Extrapolating the current scale, the ‘yellow’ I should be able to get to yellow-15 at that scale before one would hit black.
I would expect something like oklab to keep the lightness consistent across the 0–12 across any color scheme. I would either expect 12 to be nearer to black or the scale extended to 15 for these darker shades missing in almost every color which is less likely to break existing code.
Currently I’m extending blue-15, lime-15, violet-15, yellow-15, orange-15, & red-15 for --surface-* values in a theme just to get these necessary values for my OLED-compatible theme, & while I have the ability to make my own color scales, surely I’m not the only one experiencing this issue for the default setup.
excellent observations and nice customizations 👍🏻
these colors have been tested across a lot of bummer screens too, and account for that variety.
the next version of colors will be based on oklch and will feature much of what you're doing as well. so expect these upgrades in OPv2 (coming soon). it'll also be a scale of 1-16