MPVolume Hud doesn't disappear with AVPlayerViewController

[Gianpiero Spinelli]

I have a UIViewController with an AVPlayerViewController in it. I disable MPVolume Hud in the ViewController, and it doesn't appear until I play the AVPlayer in the AVPlayerViewController. I know that with

avplayercontroller.showsPlaybackControls = false

the hud disappears, but the problem is that every control disappears, and I need controls, and I prefer to use system controls instead of custom ones.

SubtleVolume works, but when I play the Player controller both the hud and SubtleVolume are visible.

I tried to create a MPVolume and add it to the app window, to the player controller view, but the hud is still visible.

let volumeView = MPVolumeView(frame: CGRect.zero)
if let appDelegate = UIApplication.shared.delegate as? AppDelegate, let window = appDelegate.window {
    window.insertSubview(volumeView, at: 0)
}

I've tried almost everything, but I can't figure out what is the problem.

[Andrea Mazzini]

Hey @gianpispi
I'm not sure I understand the issue, what is your desired result?
Consider that SubtleVolume creates internally a MPVolumeView as you can see here.
The volume view can't be completely hidden, or the default volume UI will kick in, so I just hide it with a fraction of alpha, as you can see here

[Gianpiero Spinelli]

Hey @andreamazz
Thanks for heading back!

Sorry fro the bad explanation. I add the SubtleVolume to my view controller. It hides the Volume HUD perfectly until I start the AVPlayer into the AVPlayerViewController added as child to my first view controller. When I play the video, and try to change the volume, the hud becomes visible as SubtleVolume does. So I have two volume indicators.

I tried to add a MPVolumeView to the AVPlayerViewController, but it doesn't change anything.

[Andrea Mazzini]

Can you post a screenshot?
If I understand correctly you want the media controls visible, but not the volume bar, right?

[Gianpiero Spinelli]

So the problem is this basically: I have both, and the status bar doesn't disappear.

Thank you!