[DOC] Proposal for an updated EDS book logo
acocac opened this issue · comments
Describe the proposed improvement to the documentation
Hi folks!
Additional to my WIP #117 aimed at improving guidelines and documentation of the EDS book, I’m excited to share recent developments in our branding 🎨 . I would like to propose a new intentionally designed logo for the EDS book.
The current logo (please see it below) only reflects the digitalisation of the planet earth, in this case represented by three consecutive icons: the natural earth (left), binary code referring to the means i.e. data, code, software, etc (mid) and digital earth (right).
The updated logo builds upon the original one, but highlighting new components:
- People network icons at the start and end of EDS initials indicating an end-to-end community-driven goal i.e. improving scientific software and data management practises through the publication of FAIR peer-reviewed computational notebooks.
- Rope knots (proposal 1) or plugs (proposal 2) connecting all capital letters referring to a healthy and strong collaboration.
- Lettermark-oriented. The original logo missed the name. The proposed versions comprise the initials to make it easy to remember and recognise.
Here's a comparison of two variants of the proposed logo (feel free to vote 🐶 or 🐱):
| Rope knot (:dog:) | Plugs (:cat:) |
|---|---|
 |
 |
Who can help?
Thoughts from the EDS book community and friends are welcome. I'm completely open to playing around with:
- the final colours (is a B&W version ok?)
- whether or not to have a "binary code" icon.
- whether or not to have a "rope knots” or “plugs”
- whether or not to have a “people network icons”
Feel free to tag anyone who might be interested. I’m aiming to release the new logo with the updated documentation in March.
I also attach PDF versions of both logo variants which include some variations for stickers or social networks.
Additional information
I initially designed the proposed logo in MS Powerpoint using the default gallery of icons which are free to use with no copyright.
Thanks to @aleesteele, I recently learnt about penpot, a great open-source design prototyping tool. If you’re familiar with the tool or want to try your graphic designer skills, I can provide access to the EDS book penpot project group.
Shamelessly tagging some folks @scotthosking @annefou @edwardchalstrey1 @NHomer-Edi @timo0thy @malvikasharan @KirstieJane for comment on this!
Temptative vote here 🐶 or 🐱
Ooh these look great. 😍 Let me think a bit and come back to this during our collaboration cafe this week.
A minor suggestion you can feel free to ignore, but maybe there's a way to include the full words like below (but better)
@edwardchalstrey1 thanks for the quick reply and ideas. I forgot to include PDF files of both variants which include the name below the logo!! Please see them below.
PDF versions of both logo variants:
Temptative vote here 🐶 or 🐱
I like Rope knot 🐶
Both look terrific but I am slightly in favour of 🐱 - having in mind that (apart from the obvious meaning) the EDS Book also serves as a 'plug' to promote good coding practices!
And by the way another small comment that is ignorable - just wondering if there's any possibility that the characters 'E''D''S' could be stuck a little bit closer together?
Anyway, that's really some great work @acocac !
The Plugs (🐱) get my vote!
Thanks @edwardchalstrey1 @tinaok @timo0thy @NHomer-Edi for your valuable thoughts and vote. I'll wait for others feedback and update everyone soon!
So far, we have a draw, 🐶 (2) and 🐱 (2)
👋 @edwardchalstrey1 @tinaok @timo0thy @NHomer-Edi @malvikasharan @annefou @scotthosking thanks for all your valuable inputs. Please find below the final version of EDS book logo. We hope to have a professional designer to improve it.
A recap of my main points:
- the final colours (is a B&W version ok?) > no comments, but B&W seems to look ok.
- whether or not to have a "binary code" icon > no comments. It think it's ok to maintain the same icons of the first logo. This also includes the Earth logo, which I initially replaced by a more abstracted version, however the icon refers to the Firefox browser.
- whether or not to have a "rope knots” or “plugs” > plugs seems to reflect the modularity of Jupyter notebooks. Ropes were proposed to reflect the community aspects, however this seems to be explicit with people network icons
- whether or not to have a “people network icons” > no comments
| Logo | Logo with Name | Sticker |
|---|---|---|
 |
 |
 |