[BUG]docker compose up is not working.
hisashiyamaguchi opened this issue · comments
I'm getting started ULS and trying to docker compose up on simple directory, but it's not working. Here comes what I'm trying.
$ uname -a
Darwin tyo-mpy1d 19.6.0 Darwin Kernel Version 19.6.0: Thu May 6 00:48:39 PDT 2021; root:xnu-6153.141.33~1/RELEASE_X86_64 x86_64
$ pwd
~/uls/docker-compose/simple
$ git branch
* main
$ docker -v
Docker version 20.10.0, build 7287ab3
$ cat docker-compose.yml
version: "3.0"
services:
etp-threat:
image: uls:latest
restart: always
env_file: etp-threat.env
volumes:
- type: bind
source: ~/.edgerc
target: /opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc
$ docker login
Authenticating with existing credentials...
Login Succeeded
$ docker compose -D up
The new 'docker compose' command is currently experimental. To provide feedback or request new features please open issues at https://github.com/docker/compose-cli
WARN[0000] invalid non-bool value for BUILDX_NO_DEFAULT_LOAD:
DEBU[0000] serving grpc connection
[+] Building 1.5s (2/3)
[+] Building 1.6s (3/3) FINISHED
=> [internal] load build definition from Dockerfile 0.0s
=> => transferring dockerfile: 52B 0.0s
=> [internal] load .dockerignore 0.0s
=> => transferring context: 2B 0.0s
=> ERROR [internal] load metadata for docker.io/library/uls:latest 1.6s
------
> [internal] load metadata for docker.io/library/uls:latest:
------
failed to solve: rpc error: code = Unknown desc = failed to solve with frontend dockerfile.v0: failed to create LLB definition: pull access denied, repository does not exist or may require authorization: server message: insufficient_scope: authorization failed
Thanks for trying ULS!
You may need to update slight the docker-compose.yml file, I spotted a typo we'll fix:
Replace
image: uls:latest
by
image: akamai/uls:latest
Also, I think docker compose YAML doesn't perform any shell-type substitution so you may need to replace
source: ~/.edgerc
by
source: /Users/<your-mac-userid>/.edgerc
Please give it a shot and let us know!
Thanks for the quick follow-up @bitonio - After applying changes that you gave me, I'm now having another issue. It's not urgent though.
$ cat docker-compose.yml
version: "3.0"
services:
etp-threat:
image: akamai/uls:latest
restart: always
env_file: etp-threat.env
volumes:
- type: bind
source: /Users/hyamaguc/.edgerc
target: /opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc
$ cat etp-threat.env
# This is a sample ENV file for EAA - Threat logs (via ULS)
# GENERIC Config
ULS_LOGLEVEL=DEBUG
# INPUT CONFIGURATION
# THE INPUT PRODUCT [EAA | ETP | MFA]
ULS_INPUT=ETP
# THE INPUT FEED
# EAA: [ ADMIN | ACCESS]
# ETP: [ THREAT | AUP ]
# MFA: [ POLICY | AUTH ]
ULS_FEED=THREAT
# INPUT FORRMAT
ULS_FORMAT=JSON
# LOCATION OF THE AKAMAI .EDGERC FILE
ULS_EDGERC='/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'
# RELEVANT SECTION WITHIN THE EDGERC FILE
ULS_SECTION=assets
# OUTPUT CONFIGURATION
# OUTPUT PATH [ TCP / UDP / HTTP ]
ULS_OUTPUT=TCP
# OUTPUT TARGET HOST
ULS_OUTPUT_HOST=192.168.86.34
# OUTPUT TARGET PORT
ULS_OUTPUT_PORT=9091
$ docker login
Authenticating with existing credentials...
Login Succeeded
$ docker compose -D up
The new 'docker compose' command is currently experimental. To provide feedback or request new features please open issues at https://github.com/docker/compose-cli
[+] Running 1/1
⠿ simple_etp-threat_1 Restarted 0.3s
Attaching to simple_etp-threat_1
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:53,195 ULS D Logging initialized
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:53,195 ULS D UlsMonitoring monitoring thread started...
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:53,195 ULS D UlsMonitoring sleeping 300 sec...
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:53,195 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected product: ETP
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:53,195 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected feed: THREAT
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:53,195 ULS D UlsInputCli - CLI Command: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:53,197 ULS D UlsInputCli - started PID[9]: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:55,202 ULS E UlsInputCli - process [9] exited RC=1, REASON: Traceback (most recent call last):
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 443, in <module>
etp-threat | main()
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 382, in main
etp-threat | client_token=config.client_token,
etp-threat | AttributeError: 'EdgeGridConfig' object has no attribute 'client_token'
etp-threat | -
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:55,202 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected product: ETP
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:55,202 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected feed: THREAT
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:55,202 ULS D UlsInputCli - CLI Command: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:55,204 ULS D UlsInputCli - started PID[10]: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:57,211 ULS E UlsInputCli - process [10] exited RC=1, REASON: Traceback (most recent call last):
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 443, in <module>
etp-threat | main()
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 382, in main
etp-threat | client_token=config.client_token,
etp-threat | AttributeError: 'EdgeGridConfig' object has no attribute 'client_token'
etp-threat | -
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:57,211 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected product: ETP
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:57,211 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected feed: THREAT
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:57,211 ULS D UlsInputCli - CLI Command: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:57,214 ULS D UlsInputCli - started PID[11]: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:59,225 ULS E UlsInputCli - process [11] exited RC=1, REASON: Traceback (most recent call last):
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 443, in <module>
etp-threat | main()
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 382, in main
etp-threat | client_token=config.client_token,
etp-threat | AttributeError: 'EdgeGridConfig' object has no attribute 'client_token'
etp-threat | -
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:51:59,226 ULS C Not able to start the CLI for ETP. See above errors. Giving up after 3 retries.
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:08,013 ULS D Logging initialized
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:08,013 ULS D UlsMonitoring monitoring thread started...
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:08,014 ULS D UlsMonitoring sleeping 300 sec...
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:08,014 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected product: ETP
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:08,014 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected feed: THREAT
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:08,014 ULS D UlsInputCli - CLI Command: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:08,016 ULS D UlsInputCli - started PID[9]: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:10,027 ULS E UlsInputCli - process [9] exited RC=1, REASON: Traceback (most recent call last):
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 443, in <module>
etp-threat | main()
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 382, in main
etp-threat | client_token=config.client_token,
etp-threat | AttributeError: 'EdgeGridConfig' object has no attribute 'client_token'
etp-threat | -
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:10,027 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected product: ETP
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:10,027 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected feed: THREAT
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:10,028 ULS D UlsInputCli - CLI Command: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:10,030 ULS D UlsInputCli - started PID[10]: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:12,041 ULS E UlsInputCli - process [10] exited RC=1, REASON: Traceback (most recent call last):
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 443, in <module>
etp-threat | main()
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 382, in main
etp-threat | client_token=config.client_token,
etp-threat | AttributeError: 'EdgeGridConfig' object has no attribute 'client_token'
etp-threat | -
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:12,041 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected product: ETP
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:12,041 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected feed: THREAT
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:12,041 ULS D UlsInputCli - CLI Command: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:12,045 ULS D UlsInputCli - started PID[11]: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:14,056 ULS E UlsInputCli - process [11] exited RC=1, REASON: Traceback (most recent call last):
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 443, in <module>
etp-threat | main()
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 382, in main
etp-threat | client_token=config.client_token,
etp-threat | AttributeError: 'EdgeGridConfig' object has no attribute 'client_token'
etp-threat | -
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:53:14,056 ULS C Not able to start the CLI for ETP. See above errors. Giving up after 3 retries.
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:32,916 ULS D Logging initialized
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:32,916 ULS D UlsMonitoring monitoring thread started...
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:32,916 ULS D UlsMonitoring sleeping 300 sec...
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:32,916 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected product: ETP
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:32,916 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected feed: THREAT
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:32,917 ULS D UlsInputCli - CLI Command: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:32,918 ULS D UlsInputCli - started PID[8]: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:34,928 ULS E UlsInputCli - process [8] exited RC=1, REASON: Traceback (most recent call last):
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 443, in <module>
etp-threat | main()
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 382, in main
etp-threat | client_token=config.client_token,
etp-threat | AttributeError: 'EdgeGridConfig' object has no attribute 'client_token'
etp-threat | -
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:34,929 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected product: ETP
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:34,929 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected feed: THREAT
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:34,929 ULS D UlsInputCli - CLI Command: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:34,932 ULS D UlsInputCli - started PID[9]: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:36,938 ULS E UlsInputCli - process [9] exited RC=1, REASON: Traceback (most recent call last):
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 443, in <module>
etp-threat | main()
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 382, in main
etp-threat | client_token=config.client_token,
etp-threat | AttributeError: 'EdgeGridConfig' object has no attribute 'client_token'
etp-threat | -
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:36,938 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected product: ETP
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:36,938 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected feed: THREAT
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:36,938 ULS D UlsInputCli - CLI Command: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:36,942 ULS D UlsInputCli - started PID[10]: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:38,948 ULS E UlsInputCli - process [10] exited RC=1, REASON: Traceback (most recent call last):
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 443, in <module>
etp-threat | main()
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 382, in main
etp-threat | client_token=config.client_token,
etp-threat | AttributeError: 'EdgeGridConfig' object has no attribute 'client_token'
etp-threat | -
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 22:58:38,948 ULS C Not able to start the CLI for ETP. See above errors. Giving up after 3 retries.
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:13,548 ULS D Logging initialized
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:13,549 ULS D UlsMonitoring monitoring thread started...
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:13,549 ULS D UlsMonitoring sleeping 300 sec...
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:13,549 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected product: ETP
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:13,549 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected feed: THREAT
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:13,549 ULS D UlsInputCli - CLI Command: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:13,550 ULS D UlsInputCli - started PID[9]: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:15,559 ULS E UlsInputCli - process [9] exited RC=1, REASON: Traceback (most recent call last):
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 443, in <module>
etp-threat | main()
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 382, in main
etp-threat | client_token=config.client_token,
etp-threat | AttributeError: 'EdgeGridConfig' object has no attribute 'client_token'
etp-threat | -
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:15,560 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected product: ETP
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:15,560 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected feed: THREAT
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:15,560 ULS D UlsInputCli - CLI Command: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:15,564 ULS D UlsInputCli - started PID[10]: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:17,576 ULS E UlsInputCli - process [10] exited RC=1, REASON: Traceback (most recent call last):
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 443, in <module>
etp-threat | main()
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 382, in main
etp-threat | client_token=config.client_token,
etp-threat | AttributeError: 'EdgeGridConfig' object has no attribute 'client_token'
etp-threat | -
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:17,576 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected product: ETP
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:17,576 ULS D UlsInputCli - selected feed: THREAT
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:17,576 ULS D UlsInputCli - CLI Command: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:17,578 ULS D UlsInputCli - started PID[11]: ['python3', 'ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp', '--edgerc', "'/opt/akamai-uls/.edgerc'", '--section', 'assets', '--user-agent-prefix', 'ULS/0.9.0_ETP-THREAT', 'event', 'threat', '-f']
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:19,582 ULS E UlsInputCli - process [11] exited RC=1, REASON: Traceback (most recent call last):
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 443, in <module>
etp-threat | main()
etp-threat | File "/opt/akamai-uls/uls/ext/cli-etp/bin/akamai-etp", line 382, in main
etp-threat | client_token=config.client_token,
etp-threat | AttributeError: 'EdgeGridConfig' object has no attribute 'client_token'
etp-threat | -
etp-threat | 2021-07-26 23:03:19,583 ULS C Not able to start the CLI for ETP. See above errors. Giving up after 3 retries.
panic: runtime error: invalid memory address or nil pointer dereference
[signal SIGSEGV: segmentation violation code=0x1 addr=0x18 pc=0x2759661]
goroutine 113 [running]:
github.com/docker/compose-cli/local.(*composeService).attachContainerStreams.func1(0x34c7c00, 0xc00055a100, 0x34aac80, 0xc00003a1c0, 0x0, 0x0)
github.com/docker/compose-cli/local/compose.go:412 +0x61
created by github.com/docker/compose-cli/local.(*composeService).attachContainerStreams
github.com/docker/compose-cli/local/compose.go:409 +0x12c
It looks like your .edgerc file is missing the client_token variable in the [default] section.
We know these can be hard to get started, we have added a special documentation about how to configure credentials.
Please check it out:
https://github.com/akamai/uls/blob/main/docs/AKAMAI_API_CREDENTIALS.md#etp-open-api-reporting
can you please change your docker-compose.yml to use the akamai/uls:development image instead of the latest image?
I've just added a .edgerc verification logic in order to give a more detailed output on missing variables within the config file.
Please provide any feedback on this topic.
Hi @hisashiyamaguchi ,
have you been able to re-test the issue with the mentioned "development" branch?
Not yet - let me try later. I'm being stacked with some other issues now... will let you know if those might be bugs.
This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.