Cannot build with XCFramework in plugin

Question

Cannot build with XCFramework in plugin

ddfreiling opened this issue 4 years ago · comments

Environment
Provide version numbers for the following components (information can be retrieved by running tns info in your project folder or by inspecting the package.json of the project):

CLI: 6.3.3
Cross-platform modules: 6.3.2
iOS Runtime: 6.3.0
Android Runtime (if applicable):
Plugin(s): https://github.com/Notalib/nativescript-webview-ext/tree/ba57098ef56a846720febeb164324944a523a8b9

Describe the bug

A project with a plugin which includes a .XCFramework in its /platforms/ios can prepare just fine, but when you try to build it, it fails because of the strip-dynamic-framework-architectures.sh script, which does not seem to support XCFrameworks.

To Reproduce

tns create mydemo --ng
tns plugin add @nota/nativescript-webview-ext@xcframework
tns build ios

Expected behavior
Expect that tns build does not try to strip out architectures from an .XCFramework from a plugin. https://github.com/NativeScript/ios-runtime/blob/master/build/project-template/internal/strip-dynamic-framework-architectures.sh should probably be updated to support .XCFramework libraries.

Sample project

See repro. Plugin source at https://github.com/Notalib/nativescript-webview-ext/tree/ba57098ef56a846720febeb164324944a523a8b9

Additional context

I added some debug logging to strip-dynamic-framework-architectures.sh and got this output. It seems it's trying to use lipo to remove the only architecture of a non-fat Framework inside an XCFramework.

==========================================
strip-dynamic-frameworks
- with path: /Users/b044554/code/tns-plugins/nativescript-webview-ext/demo/platforms/ios/build/Debug-iphonesimulator/demo.app/Frameworks
- valid archs: i386 x86_64
==========================================
Stripping frameworks in /Users/b044554/code/tns-plugins/nativescript-webview-ext/demo/platforms/ios/build/Debug-iphonesimulator/demo.app/Frameworks
- skip ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-x86_64-simulator/NotaWebViewExt.framework/_CodeSignature/CodeResources
- get arch for ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-x86_64-simulator/NotaWebViewExt.framework/NotaWebViewExt
- got Non-fat file: ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-x86_64-simulator/NotaWebViewExt.framework/NotaWebViewExt is architecture: x86_64
- skip ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-x86_64-simulator/NotaWebViewExt.framework/Headers/NotaWebViewExt-Swift.h
- skip ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-x86_64-simulator/NotaWebViewExt.framework/Headers/NotaWebViewExt.h
- skip ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-x86_64-simulator/NotaWebViewExt.framework/Modules/NotaWebViewExt.swiftmodule/x86_64-apple-ios-simulator.swiftinterface
- skip ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-x86_64-simulator/NotaWebViewExt.framework/Modules/NotaWebViewExt.swiftmodule/x86_64-apple-ios-simulator.swiftdoc
- skip ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-x86_64-simulator/NotaWebViewExt.framework/Modules/NotaWebViewExt.swiftmodule/x86_64.swiftdoc
- skip ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-x86_64-simulator/NotaWebViewExt.framework/Modules/NotaWebViewExt.swiftmodule/x86_64.swiftinterface
- skip ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-x86_64-simulator/NotaWebViewExt.framework/Modules/module.modulemap
- skip ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-x86_64-simulator/NotaWebViewExt.framework/Info.plist
- skip ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-arm64/NotaWebViewExt.framework/_CodeSignature/CodeResources
- get arch for ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-arm64/NotaWebViewExt.framework/NotaWebViewExt
- got Non-fat file: ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-arm64/NotaWebViewExt.framework/NotaWebViewExt is architecture: arm64
- remove arch arm64 in ./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-arm64/NotaWebViewExt.framework/NotaWebViewExt
fatal error: lipo: input file (./NotaWebViewExt.xcframework/ios-arm64/NotaWebViewExt.framework/NotaWebViewExt) must be a fat file when the -remove option is specified
Command PhaseScriptExecution failed with a nonzero exit code

Martin Bektchiev · Answer 1 · Thu Jan 16 2020 18:41:04 GMT+0800 (China Standard Time)

Hi @ddfreiling, I tried to reproduce the issue, but it seems not reproducible with Xcode 11.3. What is your version (please check with xcodebuild -version). I got the following output of the strip script:

Stripping frameworks in /Users/bektchiev/work/_scratch/mydemo/platforms/ios/build/Debug-iphonesimulator/mydemo.app/Frameworks
Architectures of ./NotaWebViewExt.framework/NotaWebViewExt: x86_64
Architectures of ./NativeScript.framework/NativeScript: i386 x86_64 armv7 arm64
Stripped ./NativeScript.framework/NativeScript of architectures: armv7 arm64
Code Signing ./NativeScript.framework/NativeScript with Identity -
/usr/bin/codesign --force --sign - --preserve-metadata=identifier,entitlements ./NativeScript.framework/NativeScript
./NativeScript.framework/NativeScript: replacing existing signature
Architectures of ./TNSWidgets.framework/TNSWidgets: i386 x86_64 armv7 arm64
Stripped ./TNSWidgets.framework/TNSWidgets of architectures: armv7 arm64
Code Signing ./TNSWidgets.framework/TNSWidgets with Identity -
/usr/bin/codesign --force --sign - --preserve-metadata=identifier,entitlements ./TNSWidgets.framework/TNSWidgets
./TNSWidgets.framework/TNSWidgets: replacing existing signature
~/work/_scratch/mydemo/platforms/ios

As you can see the .xcframework bundle isn't copied by Xcode into the .app/Frameworks directory but only the relevant platform's .framework. Maybe its something that Apple have changed in the latest Xcode version...

I've verified that the plugin version is correct and contains the .XCFramework in ./node_modules/@nota/nativescript-webview-ext/platforms/ios/NotaWebViewExt.xcframework