Giters

JuliaNeuroscience / NIfTI.jl

Julia module for reading/writing NIfTI MRI files

Geek Repo:Geek Repo

Github PK Tool:Github PK Tool

Transfer to the JuliaHealth organization?

DilumAluthge opened this issue · comments

commented

Any objection to moving this repo to the JuliaHealth organization?

cc: @Tokazama
cc: @simonster
cc: @notZaki
cc: @ViralBShah

See also: JuliaHealth/DICOM.jl#48

commented

I'm fine with this. It will actually probably be good to have an org where it could get more attention.

commented

I should also note that I made JuliaNeuroscience that may be a more appropriate place for it

commented

Either seems fine! I agree that a more domain-specific org will be better for it than the IO org.

I've added JuliaNeuroscience to the list (https://juliahealth.org/related-organizations/) which will hopefully also increase discoverability.

commented

Whatever is decided: DICOM.jl and NIfTI.jl should be in the same organization.

commented

DICOM.jl now lives in JuliaHealth: https://github.com/JuliaHealth/DICOM.jl

We'd be happy to accept NIfTI.jl into JuliaHealth.

Let me know if you want to be added as a member of JuliaHealth, or if you need additional permissions to transfer repositories.

commented

Go for it!

commented

I think @Tokazama should make the final decision. I am just here as user that regularly looks by here to wait until @Tokazama awesome overhauled implementation lands to master.

commented

My only hesitation with transferring it to JuliaHealth is that it NIfTI is a neuro specific format that isn't commonly used outside of research. If JulaiHealth includes any physiologically related package then the GIFTI and CIFTI formats as well as the 10+ neurophysiology related formats should be supported by packages under JuliaHealth. I know that the the JuliaHealth description says "We use the Julia programming language to improve medicine, health care, public health, and biomedical research.", but if thats broad enough to include any biologically derived data then most of BioJulia will should be in JuliaHealth.

Now with all that said, if that really is the intention of JuliaHealth and it's best for the future of these packages I'm in favor of moving it to JuliaHealth.

commented

I use NifTI as a general replacement for DICOM in the context of tomographic imaging, independent if neuro or not (but I am of course aware of the origins of NIfTI). So JuliaHealth is fine IMHO.
Independent of the organization I am more eagerly waiting that this package actually gets into a better shape, which is once your work lands ;-)

commented

@Tokazama It's entirely up to you!

My only hesitation with transferring it to JuliaHealth is that it NIfTI is a neuro specific format that isn't commonly used outside of research.

Based on this description, probably the repo would be better suited for JuliaNeuroscience?

commented

@Tokazama It's entirely up to you!

My only hesitation with transferring it to JuliaHealth is that it NIfTI is a neuro specific format that isn't commonly used outside of research.

Based on this description, probably the repo would be better suited for JuliaNeuroscience?

I do think it will fit better in JuliaNeuroscience than JuliaIO.

That way you can centralize all of the neurophysiology and neuroscience research-specific file formats in JuliaNeuroscience.

commented

Sounds good. I don't think I have permissions to transfer repos from JuliIO. Do I need to give someone someone permissions for JuliaNeuroscience?

commented

@tknopp , I think you have owner permissions for this repo. Would you like me to provide you with access to JuliaNeuroscience so that you can transfer the repo?

commented

I can do so

commented

done :-)

commented

I actually have no rights to close this anymore :-) @Tokazama Habe you rights?

commented

Thanks! You should also have write access now too.